Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted (edited)
25 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I’ve come to terms with no Skubal, but they need to get someone who resembles an ace, or at least a SOLID #2. Would be pretty bummed if they end up getting a few 3’s and 4’s… or worse.

Not exactly Aces, but Rogers,  Peralta,  or King would be solid TOR starters and would likely be in the Cubs range contract wise.

Im thinking Peralta starting to be a good possibility 

Edited by chibears55
  • Replies 729
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
2 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Only real criticism i have of Hoyer is his constant go to of signing low cost veterans, guys coming off injuries, and released players hoping to strike gold but its usually just payroll eaters that mostly get waived eventually. 

As far as whatever payroll is,  if criticism is due, it should be pointed at Ricketts, Hoyer and his staff just need to do a little better job at evaluating who to spend it on to make sure they have a full competitive roster

I get it, but really how much does that end up costing. They signed Tyler Austin (or is it Austin Tyler?), Conforto, Carlson and McCormick. So easy to criticize the guys who did poorly. But by throwing darts at the wall they got Conforto. He was worth all the contracts those guys got. He signed Rolison and Webb cheaply. But again, easy to criticize signings like Theilbar and Harvey. The year before he got Keller, Theilbar, brought in Pomoranz, signed Kelly. But people will find the trade for Pressley to criticize him. Because of the restraints Ricketts puts in him he has to take risks in guys. And the ones that hit no one says a word about. They only comment on the misses. 

Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

Who though? Guys have made a good argument that King and Peralta shouldn’t be offered a contract. So that leave Rogers, Gray, Gausman, Holmes? Am I missing someone? Would those guys qualify as solid #2’s? There is only 1 ace available. I would be happy with 3 guys if 2 came from Taira, Holmes, Gray, Rogers, Gausman and a 3rd came from Mahle, Peterson, May. Soroka, , etc…. Obviously there are some combos I like better than others, but depending on what they can spend, some combos might not be available. 

These are good points and I fully agree, it’s slim pickens. Rogers Id classify as a solid 2, despite a higher ERA than I’d like to see last season. Taira has that type of aura too but he’s unproven, so let’s snag both of them and then a 3–4 type guy, say Peterson. I’d be good with that pitching-wise given the options. 

The trade market would be the place to go for ace type or bonafide #2… but the point you made previously about 1-year guys and an unknown 2027 season is a real problem. 

Nonetheless, I don’t know what to expect but I’m here for ride.

Edited by Nolo
Posted

Clay Holmes Cubs debut left a lot to be desired, and seeing him come back as anything more than a 4-5 in our rotation gives me great pause.  

 

Posted (edited)

don’t know if this has been posted yet but Cade Horton is throwing a baseball! 

 

Edited by Nolo
  • Like 3
  • Love 1
Posted (edited)
27 minutes ago, BobbyD3 said:

Clay Holmes Cubs debut left a lot to be desired, and seeing him come back as anything more than a 4-5 in our rotation gives me great pause.  

 

Then if he comes back you will experience great pause. There is no way he will be a 4 or a 5. At least not at the start of the season. If they sign Rogers and then Steele comes back to pre injury results and somehow Cabrera figures it out or Brown comes back and starts, he could drop to a 4. Then after the break Horton comes back, so he drops to a 5. But that’s wishful thinking and everything going right for the Cubs. If come August Holmes is a 4 or a 5, the Cubs will be a 95+ win team. 

Edited by Rcal10
Posted
2 hours ago, Nolo said:

I’ve come to terms with no Skubal, but they need to get someone who resembles an ace, or at least a SOLID #2. Would be pretty bummed if they end up getting a few 3’s and 4’s… or worse.

They have a whole bunch of money to spend on SP, they'll get some good arms.  If they can get 3 quality SP and maybe a cheaper upside guy plus a Civale/Rea type SP I'm happy.

Luckily the pen is in better shape than the last couple of offseasons so they don't have to spend as much there.

What they do in the OF is the real mystery.  I'd think they'd ideally want to have their new catcher and most of the rotation signed before the lockout.  We'll see.  Hopefully mostly lesser pieces after the lockout.

I could see this not being a good year to save payroll for late opportunistic signings, unless "late" means running out the clock right before the lockout starts.

Posted
19 hours ago, Nolo said:

Would you rather see Cubs sign:

Taira/Rogers/May

or

Taira/Holmes/Peterson

Assume no other SPs are signed in addition.

Holmes and Peterson are the safer options but wasn’t Jed looking to add swing and miss? 

Posted
12 hours ago, Nolo said:

don’t know if this has been posted yet but Cade Horton is throwing a baseball! 

 

Consider it a mirage. or consider it their closer/high leverage relief pitcher throwing. 

Posted
21 minutes ago, CubinNY said:

Consider it a mirage. or consider it their closer/high leverage relief pitcher throwing. 

For the ‘27 season I could see him back as a late inning/high leverage relief pitcher. But, IMO, the plan is still for him to start. Regardless, him throwing now isn’t anything that excites me. So much more time to go in rehab and so many hurdles overcome. There will most likely be setbacks. It just happens. So until he is actually back, I can’t get too excited about each step he takes. 

Posted

The internal brace procedure has clearly changed the calculus on having a 2nd TJ for the better.  It's certainly worse than having your first but the success stories are no longer just Nate Eovaldi, Jameson Taillon, and a bunch of relievers.

Posted
22 minutes ago, Bertz said:

The internal brace procedure has clearly changed the calculus on having a 2nd TJ for the better.  It's certainly worse than having your first but the success stories are no longer just Nate Eovaldi, Jameson Taillon, and a bunch of relievers.

Exactly. Which is why I feel the plan with Horton is he remains a starting pitcher. But, first things first. He needs to be healthy again. 

Posted
1 hour ago, CubinNY said:

Consider it a mirage. or consider it their closer/high leverage relief pitcher throwing. 

He'll likely be in same boat as Steele was last season..

Hope he can return to maybe get a few starts in 2nd half, and no setbacks, if it late in season,  then maybe a few relief outings.

Posted

I see Zac Gallen name coming up alot the last couple days. 

Hed likely be someone Hoyer could go after if he adds a 3rd starter this offseason, someone he could offer a 2 year low cost prove it deal with possibly the 2nd year as an option year.

Posted
5 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I see Zac Gallen name coming up alot the last couple days. 

Hed likely be someone Hoyer could go after if he adds a 3rd starter this offseason, someone he could offer a 2 year low cost prove it deal with possibly the 2nd year as an option year.

Yikes 

Posted
21 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I see Zac Gallen name coming up alot the last couple days. 

Hed likely be someone Hoyer could go after if he adds a 3rd starter this offseason, someone he could offer a 2 year low cost prove it deal with possibly the 2nd year as an option year.

He shouldn't get more than a minor league deal with a big league camp invite as bad as he's been the last 2 years.  Hell no.

Posted

I think it's pretty reasonable to think Gallen can bounce back, at minimum to his 2025 form.  I'd be down assuming he's sufficiently far down the depth chart.  Broadly:

- If Zac Gallen is the 4th best SP we add, I'll be pretty happy

- If Zac Gallen is the 3rd best SP we add, I'll be annoyed but get over it

- If Zac Gallen is the 2nd best SP we add, I'll be pissed

- If Zac Gallen is the best SP we add, that's a heroine to the forehead scenario

Posted
16 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I see Zac Gallen name coming up alot the last couple days. 

Hed likely be someone Hoyer could go after if he adds a 3rd starter this offseason, someone he could offer a 2 year low cost prove it deal with possibly the 2nd year as an option year.

He was arguably one of the worst SP's in 2026.   Jed won't sign him, unless he fails to sign all the other options.  Even Colin Rea was much better last season.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Bertz said:

I think it's pretty reasonable to think Gallen can bounce back, at minimum to his 2025 form.  I'd be down assuming he's sufficiently far down the depth chart.  Broadly:

- If Zac Gallen is the 4th best SP we add, I'll be pretty happy

- If Zac Gallen is the 3rd best SP we add, I'll be annoyed but get over it

- If Zac Gallen is the 2nd best SP we add, I'll be pissed

- If Zac Gallen is the best SP we add, that's a heroine to the forehead scenario

Like Black Widow or Captain Marvel or did you have someone else in mind?

  • Haha 2
Posted (edited)
10 minutes ago, mul21 said:

Like Black Widow or Captain Marvel or did you have someone else in mind?

Ha!  I typed it without the E at the end initially but autocorrect suggested with the E and I completely spaced on it being a homophone

Edited by Bertz
  • Haha 1
Posted

Pass hard on Dustin May. Multiple good pitching organizations cannot get this guy to a good space. For 3/$52m you're not far off from what you'd expect Clay Holmes to get. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...