I wanted to make it A-/B+. Since there's no + and -, I graded it "A".
Before the dead line, I wanted Holmes as a rental, a younger controllable guy like Detmers or Hancock and a good RP. IMO, Holmes is arguably the 2nd best pitcher available. We got Gausman first, instead of Holmes, so I started wanting Detmers, Kirby or Hancock. Then, there was the Cerami's fake tweet or whatever that was. Like most people, I believed it, and I was happy. Then, we found that was a false alarm. At that moment, I figured a controllable SP would be too expensive, and wanted Holmes again. And, we got him + Taylor as a bonus. Yes, we gave up Rojas, who was blocked, anyway, but we didn't give up Ayers and Hartshorn. Heck, we didn't give up Pedro. I'm hoping Amaya and Ayers will be a good catching duo next year.
I didn't want to see Mo traded, but Zeferjahn looks pretty good, and Mo didn't have much value to the Cubs, because of Ayers + his struggles in Iowa. So, I'm fine with it.
As for Garrett, we have to wait, and see.
If Holmes pitches well for us, we should re-sign him. If Ayers is a real deal, we wouldn't need Carson next year. One (two?) last thing was about Shaw and Alcantara. I was surprised Alcantara wasn't traded. I guess, either nobody wanted him, or the Cubs still thinks he can be a decent corner OF, and valued him higher than other teams. And, Shaw has been on the IL for a while, and other teams didn't really want him. Maybe, Shaw or Pedro will be traded in the off season? I don't know.
Either way, again, I'm pretty happy with the deadline, because my main target was Holmes to begin with. The reason why I wanted to grade this A-/B+ was because we didn't get a young controllable SP, other than Garrett.