Is Kelly overrated, and/or Amaya underrated? One of the podcasters said out of all the Cubs free agents, re-signing Kelly should be the top priority, which I don't get. An article graded Kelly B+ and Amaya C-, and said "Kelly shines, Amaya struggles".
Their wRC+ (both with and without RISP) and fWAR were basically the same in 2026. Defensively, Amaya was rated higher. Kelly was better against LHP's. But, that's about it. Oh, Amaya had higher K%.
I'd like to re-sign Kelly at the right price (for the Cubs) for 1 or 2 years (Ayers ready or not), but somebody will outbid the Cubs for sure. I'll miss his baserunning and pitching for sure, though.😄 More than likely, I think we'll get another veteran catcher for less money than Kelly.