Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Replies 707
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
21 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Trading our presumptive RFer for a pitcher who is not appreciably better is just robbing Peter to pay Paul.  But there's more than a dozen decent Pauls on the market and like 3 decent Peters.

Like if Ben Brown was healthy but Shaw was the one with bone-itis I don't think it would change the Skubal calculus much.  It'd change the Seiya math though I guess.

'Presumptive RFer' is holding a lot of weight. A lot of his value is because he plays 2B and 3B. Just because we currently don't have a corner outfielder doesn't mean we should haircut Shaw's value because he can play out there. There's also Pedro Ramirez, who could theoretically do all of the above for us (or the Mariners). 

Pretty much all of the dozen Pauls are A. in much worse places on the age curve, and B. roughly 3-4x annually. Replacing a right field Matt Shaw, individually or in a platoon situation shouldn't cost you a Dustin May contract, mostly because his .303 xwOBA is 17 points below the league average RF production.

Old-Timey Member
Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, squally1313 said:

'Presumptive RFer' is holding a lot of weight. A lot of his value is because he plays 2B and 3B. Just because we currently don't have a corner outfielder doesn't mean we should haircut Shaw's value because he can play out there. There's also Pedro Ramirez, who could theoretically do all of the above for us (or the Mariners). 

Pretty much all of the dozen Pauls are A. in much worse places on the age curve, and B. roughly 3-4x annually. Replacing a right field Matt Shaw, individually or in a platoon situation shouldn't cost you a Dustin May contract, mostly because his .303 xwOBA is 17 points below the league average RF production.

Matt Shaw projects to a 110 wRC+ and in a SSS played like a +10 defender in RF while learning the position on the fly.  That's a 3 win player over 600 PAs

There's risk until we've seen him do it for a full season but reasonable expectation is he's a good player making the league minimum.

Edited by Bertz
Posted

Another one off the market. Interesting choice for Minny. Guess he loved pitching there.

Quote

Sonny Gray is headed back to Minnesota. The Twins announced Wednesday that they’ve signed the free-agent righty to a two-year contract. Gray, a client of McKinnis Sports, starred for Minnesota in 2022-23 and finished second in American League Cy Young voting in the latter of those two seasons.

 

Posted
27 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Matt Shaw projects to a 110 wRC+ and in a SSS played like a +10 defender in RF while learning the position on the fly.  That's a 3 win player over 600 PAs

There's risk until we've seen him do it for a full season but reasonable expectation is he's a good player making the league minimum.

I'm not sure what metric you're using defensively but I think it's pretty optimistic to project a positive defensive contributor in a corner outfield spot especially when he almost certainly has a below average arm (Savant has 85.1 mph, far below the average of 90 in RF, but not sure if that's only using infield throws or something like that. 

I'm not going to quibble with the projections because that's a slippery slope but I find it hard to believe he's projected for a 110 wRC in a full time starters role with a 79 wRC last year against RHP. Obviously people can improve, but to me the biggest difference between his 93 wRC in 2025 and his 106 wRC in 2026 was that he went from getting 75% of his PAs against RHPs to 51%. 

He can hit lefties. If we're going to keep him, please bring back Conforto. If someone wants him as a starting infielder, which he likely is today, get pitching for him. 

Verified Member
Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, Post Count Padder said:

Another one off the market. Interesting choice for Minny. Guess he loved pitching there.

 

Where you at, Jed!?

Gray got 2 years 55M so 27.5M AAV. Sounds about right after the season he had.

King, Rogers, Peralta still on the board for now. 

Edited by Nolo
Old-Timey Member
Posted

The May and Gray deals have only been slightly above Fangraphs crowd-source contract projections which makes sense if these guys are the first off the market and jumped at good offers.

North Side Contributor
Posted

The good news is that no one has come off the board that the Cubs had to have gotten. But there's going to come a point where the game of musical chairs is going to get a bit uncomfortable, so it'd be nice if the Cubs could start filling some of those seats.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Too bad.  I wanted Gray and Hancock, along with Taira and Peterson.   My backup plans are Rogers, Holmes or Shota.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Minn going for it, I wasn't aware that was an option for them

They legitimately have an interesting roster and the AL Central isn't unwinnable. Also fun to point out that Kody Clemens is the only one penciled into the starting lineup that wasn't homegrown. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, Post Count Padder said:

They legitimately have an interesting roster and the AL Central isn't unwinnable. Also fun to point out that Kody Clemens is the only one penciled into the starting lineup that wasn't homegrown. 

You're right. Gray, Ryan, Bradley, Lopez if he's healthy is a pretty good group 

Posted
40 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

That's pretty underwhelming considering we're already at that projection with no moves

I have no idea how we can possibly projected to be there already while missing almost an entire pitching staff. 

Posted
25 minutes ago, Tryptamine said:

I have no idea how we can possibly projected to be there already while missing almost an entire pitching staff. 

We were +147 last year and Fangraphs has us dropping all the way to -8 with our current roster. Huge drop but doesn't look as bad because they underperformed their run differential so much

North Side Contributor
Posted
28 minutes ago, Tryptamine said:

I have no idea how we can possibly projected to be there already while missing almost an entire pitching staff. 

The Cubs were essentially missing an entire pitching staff last year. They'll make back a few wins just from not letting guys like Taillon near an MLB org and filling them with replacement level players.

There's almost no world the Cubs will enter next year with a projection of 80 wins as long as they do something. Now, the variance of the team may include situations where 80 wins is much more plausible than it should be, but even the most underwhelming offseason you can think of in which the Cubs spend near the LT (which they will) is getting a computer to spit out 85-87 wins.

Verified Member
Posted (edited)
29 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

The Cubs were essentially missing an entire pitching staff last year. They'll make back a few wins just from not letting guys like Taillon near an MLB org and filling them with replacement level players.

There's almost no world the Cubs will enter next year with a projection of 80 wins as long as they do something. Now, the variance of the team may include situations where 80 wins is much more plausible than it should be, but even the most underwhelming offseason you can think of in which the Cubs spend near the LT (which they will) is getting a computer to spit out 85-87 wins.

I know this isn’t what you were saying, but I don’t care what any metrics or projections say, as the roster stands as of today it’s 500 team at absolute best. Obviously the season doesn’t start today but we’re talking a batting practice rotation with Brown and Horton out. 

Plus projections this early are irrelevant anyways.

Edited by Nolo
North Side Contributor
Posted
2 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I don’t care what any metrics or projections say, as the roster stands as of today it’s a just above 500 team at best. Obviously the season doesn’t start today but we’re talking a batting practice rotation with Brown and Horton out. 

Well, pythag projections would tell you it's an 80-81 win team, which was the crux of this conversation, so...it would seem you tend to agree with the projections. 

I wasn't saying it was an 85 win team today. Only that regardless of how pessimistic you are about the offseason, the team is going to add 5 wins as a minimum so we shouldn't be worried about like ZiPs telling us post-offseason that it's just a ~.500 team.

Verified Member
Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

Well, pythag projections would tell you it's an 80-81 win team, which was the crux of this conversation, so...

LOL I can’t math

When I heard 80 wins I’m like that sounds way too good. Then I divided 162 by two…

Edited by Nolo
  • Haha 1
Old-Timey Member
Posted
27 minutes ago, squally1313 said:

I'm not sure what metric you're using defensively but I think it's pretty optimistic to project a positive defensive contributor in a corner outfield spot especially when he almost certainly has a below average arm (Savant has 85.1 mph, far below the average of 90 in RF, but not sure if that's only using infield throws or something like that. 

I'm not going to quibble with the projections because that's a slippery slope but I find it hard to believe he's projected for a 110 wRC in a full time starters role with a 79 wRC last year against RHP. Obviously people can improve, but to me the biggest difference between his 93 wRC in 2025 and his 106 wRC in 2026 was that he went from getting 75% of his PAs against RHPs to 51%. 

He can hit lefties. If we're going to keep him, please bring back Conforto. If someone wants him as a starting infielder, which he likely is today, get pitching for him. 

Steamer has him at 105 vs RHP and 118 vs. LHP.  Some of this is the xwOBA cutting both ways, he was .297/.309 vs. RHP/LHP respectively, so his splits gap last year probably has some noise to it.  

For the defense he was a +2 RFer in 233 IP by both Statcast and DRS.  So prorated out to a 1200 inning full season gets you to that +10 I cited.  I don't actually think he's going to be +10, but with 90th percentile sprint speed he's going to be an easy plus.

Verified Member
Posted (edited)

Now that the stove is hot, I’ve updated my roadmap for how Jed can save this team:

Sign one of: Rogers, King

Sign one of: Peralta, Taira, Holmes

Sign one of: Peterson, Griffin, Soroka, Pivetta, Imanaga 

Sign one of: Suzuki, Sato

Sign one of: Soto, Morejon, Burke, Puk

Note: I know Morejon will trigger some people about budgeting 😆 

 

 

Edited by Nolo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...