Cubs Video
The Chicago Cubs were interested in Dustin May, but were unwilling to guarantee a third year in their pursuit of the right-handed starter, according to a source familiar with the team's thinking. May got that third year, instead, on the other side of town, agreeing to a three-year deal Tuesday morning worth $52.5 million. The $17.5-million annual average value (AAV) of the deal feels high, given that May ended the season as a little-trusted fourth starter for the Brewers and that he has ERAs of 4.96 and 4.70 over the last two years. What drew the Cubs to him was the same thing that ultimately led the Sox to push in the extra year and win the bidding war, though: he was (by far) the hardest-throwing starting pitcher not named Tarik Skubal on the market.
May's four-seamer and sinker each average over 96 miles per hour. Late in the season, Rays starter Freddy Peralta showed that level of heat, too, but Peralta's multi-year track record shows less heat, and he's not as likely to sustain that velocity over a full season as is May. Peralta is still a better pitcher, and he'll sign for considerably more than May, but the fact that May's sheer power exceeds even Peralta's explains why several teams took a keen interest in him. The ABS system shrunk the strike zone in 2026. That increased the relative value of stuff and forced teams to think about how they can find pitchers who miss bats and induce weak contact despite hitters having a smaller zone to cover. May hasn't proved he can execute well enough to dominate consistently, but unlike many available starters, he has the raw materials to do so. That boosted his market.
One Cubs Pitching Target: Sean Newcomb
Having missed out on May, the Cubs have to pivot to other options. Peralta is on their radar. So is Trevor Rogers. One less-heralded name could be an easy way for the North Siders to turn the tables on the White Sox, in a sense. Chicago has checked in on left-hander Sean Newcomb, a source said, and maintains active interest in him. Newcomb has only started 11 of the 108 games in which he's appeared since the start of 2025, but he has 182 2/3 innings pitched over that span, often working multiple innings even when appearing in relief. Newcomb has a 22.9% strikeout rate and an 8.5% walk rate over those two seasons, and he's kept the ball in the park exceptionally well. How? He induces weaker contact than most pitchers, largely because he throws hard.
Among free-agent pitchers with any chance to be starters in 2027, only Skubal and May threw harder in 2026 than did Newcomb. He sits around 95 MPH with his four-seamer and 93.5 MPH with his heavy sinker. If he were to stretch back out as a traditional starter, those numbers might come down slightly, but they're good enough to be good offerings even if that happens. His slurve is a good complement to those offerings, thanks to his plus command of it. Newcomb would be a solid pickup for a Cubs team wide huge and varied pitching needs.
May's deal underscores, however, that even Newcomb won't be cheap. One source suggested he could command a two-year deal with an AAV over $10 million, even heading into his age-34 season. Given what May just got, that would hardly be a surprise. The market is crystallizing, and the Cubs are beginning to see that there's no way to cure what ails them without spending big money.
Why Nick Fortes Has Emerged as Fit for Cubs' Catching Need
Two more consequential moves Tuesday afternoon drove home the same point. David Bednar accepted the qualifying offer the Yankees had extended him at the beginning of the month, taking one of the top two relief arms off the market. Ryan Jeffers did the same with the Twins, pushing Carson Kelly to the top of the free-agent catching class. Jeffers will make $23.15 million in 2027. Kelly isn't as good a hitter as Jeffers, but he's a much better defender, and he's caught 25% more innings over the last two seasons than Jeffers has. It looks increasingly likely that Kelly, too, will get at least $20 million in guaranteed money somewhere this winter.
In all likelihood, the Cubs will (and should) pass on bringing back Kelly at that steep a price. That's why they were among the teams to talk to the Rays Tuesday about catcher Nick Fortes, who still might be traded before Friday's deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players.
Fortes, 30, has added bat speed and become more aggressive since joining the Rays at the 2025 trade deadline. He still only batted .258/.304/.376 in 323 plate appearances for the American League champions in 2026, but he’s a well-rounded and respected defensive backstop, and he’s under team control for 2028, as well as the coming season. According to MLB Trade Rumors, he’s likely to earn around $3.4 million next year via arbitration.
Offensively, the aging profile isn’t encouraging. Fortes minimizes strikeouts thanks to great feel for making contact on pitches outside the zone, but that’s tended to interfere with the production of power numbers that match his raw power skills. He swings outside the zone too much to draw many walks, too. In the short term, though, he’s a pesky hitter who can run into a ball now and then thanks to a very flat, surprisingly quick stick.
Behind the plate, he’s an average-minus framer, but he throws well and has a good reputation with pitchers. He made a couple of head-scratching calls for pitches on which Rays hurlers got burned in October, but on the whole, he’s considered a good reader of the game and a solid adherent to the gameplans his teams have put together to get outs. He also rated as average (or slightly better) when it came to challenging calls via the ABS system in 2026.
One way or another, the Cubs have to reinforce their catching corps, but Jeffers was never on their radar. His re-up with the Twins illustrates the difficulty they'll have if they choose to re-sign Kelly, though. They need big money to bolster their pitching staff. A pickup like Fortes feels almost imperative, given the circumstances.
If May costs $17 million a year and the going rate for elite players in small roles like Bednar's and Jeffers's is over $20 million, the five or six additions the Cubs need to make figure to require $100 million in 2027 outlays alone—or an equivalent expenditure of young talent, from a farm system that doesn't have much to lose or to offer. Chicago was never quite a favorite on May, and neither Jeffers nor Bednar were ever destined to join them. With May, Evan Phillips and Jake Bauers (all solid potential targets) off the board already, though, a high-priced market is coming into focus, and the Cubs need to reduce their desperation by finding a fit or two soon. Otherwise, they might end up making big mistakes at the tail end of this month, or after the looming lockout.
Want to play the role of Cubs general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Cubs roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now