5 Guys

[Outshined_One]

Simple game for all of you. Contracts aside, you're starting a new team and can take any five players you want.

 

Mine:

 

Albert Pujols

Miguel Cabrera

Alex Rodriguez

Jose Reyes

Johan Santana

 

Who would you take?

[bukie]

Santana, Peavy, Cabrera, Pujols, Reyes

[RegulusBlue]

I'rr pray arong.

 

Pujols

Santana

Utley

Mauer

Wright

 

I tried to take age and distance from free agency into account, I guess.

 

Hard to beat your list though.

[Marco4]

A-Rod

Pujols

Utley

 

Santana

Wakefield. (What? He'll eat innings, and I think he's a top bloke, too. Its my team, isn't it?)

[Ding Dong Johnson]

Pujols

Cabrera

ARod

Hafner

Santana

[Tracer Bullet]

Santana

Utley

Mauer

Verlander

Murton

 

Kidding. Make Wright my last pick.

[alroy88]

santana

haren

peavy

francisco rodriguez

pujols

 

good pitching always beats good offense

[daske17]

Neifi

Macias

Rusch

Donovan Osborne

Carl Everett

 

What? I like high draft picks! :D

[Jazz]

A-Rod

Santana

Utley

Cabrera

Peavy

[anabiono]

sizemore

wright

utley

morneau

verlander

[daske17]

A-Rod

Santana

Utley

Cabrera

Peavy

 

By the way, nice quote in your sig ;)

[Jazz]

A-Rod

Santana

Utley

Cabrera

Peavy

 

By the way, nice quote in your sig ;)

 

oh haha, my bad. honest mistake, ill change mine.

[Drew Doughty]

Mauer

Santana

Utley

Reyes

Sizemore

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I can't believe the lack of love for PRONK!

[Transmogrified Tiger]

I can't believe the lack of love for PRONK!

 

My team plays in a real league that doesn't use the DH.

 

Pujols

Utley

Cabrera

Santana

Peavy

Edited June 28, 2007 by Transmogrified Tiger

[jersey cubs fan]

utley

reyes

santana

peavy

lackey

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I can't believe the lack of love for PRONK!

 

My team plays in a real league that doesn't use the DH.

 

if Prince Fielder can play in the NL...

[Tracer Bullet]

santana

haren

peavy

francisco rodriguez

pujols

 

good pitching always beats good offense

 

But a closer?

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Erstad

Eckstein

Pierre

Y. Molina

Jeff Weaver

 

My team is gritty and knows how to win.

[rawaction]

A lot of love for Ervin Santana.

 

Johan Santana

Peavy

Jose Reyes

Chase Utley

Justin Verlander

[davearm]

I must say I'm digging the Utley + Reyes + 3 stud pitchers formula.

 

I don't think that'd give you the 5 best individual players, but it might just be the best combination of players.

[sunnydoo]

Arod

Miggy

Prince

Russell Martin

Curtis Granderson

[Marco4]

A lot of love for Ervin Santana.

 

:-k - I meant this guy. That guy's 2006 was off the scale.

[baseball7897]

Lackey

Johan Santana

Peavy

Haren

Smoltz

 

Solid Rotation.

[CoolHandLuke]

Grady Sizemore

Joe Mauer

Hanley Ramirez

Justin Verlander

Jake Peavy

 

You may call me crazy for going with Hanley over Reyes, but I just don't like Reyes much for some reason.