Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted

Blue Jays non tendered Davis Schneider.  He's not my favorite LHH bat but he does have a minor league option, I'd be all over him.

  • Replies 909
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
47 minutes ago, squally1313 said:

Honestly, I thought the request was going to come off as a little snarky because of the real wide gap in Shaw's xwOBA v 2027 projections. Which obviously depends on how good the projections are at having a handle on age/experience related movements. I feel like conventional wisdom was a peak after a couple years pro followed by a long tail, but then I feel like the 2016-2020 Cubs had me thinking you basically start at the top and just decline at various speeds. But now there's someone like PCA, so who knows. 

I think there would be a difference between a high schooler or IFA like PCA and college prospects like KB, Schwarber etc since the former trend to get to the MLB a bit younger.

Posted
1 minute ago, Bertz said:

Blue Jays non tendered Davis Schneider.  He's not my favorite LHH bat but he does have a minor league option, I'd be all over him.

Isn’t he right handed? 

Posted
34 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Blue Jays non tendered Davis Schneider.  He's not my favorite LHH bat but he does have a minor league option, I'd be all over him.

I'm a big Davis Schneider fan. He can play all over and seems like a good dude. 

Posted
13 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I hope it’s the Sox he was visiting, but I can see the Cubs choose Itoh over Taira just to save a few bucks. Cubs seem to prefer the guys who throw low 90s instead of upper 90s with elite extension.

Posted
24 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Is he really that much worse than Taira?

Good thing is he's been healthy and consistently throws lots of innings.  Could be the new Taillon, a decent pitcher to put up innings for you.  Reliable but not exciting.

Posted
8 minutes ago, Stratos said:

Is he really that much worse than Taira?

Good thing is he's been healthy and consistently throws lots of innings.  Could be the new Taillon, a decent pitcher to put up innings for you.  Reliable but not exciting.

New Taillon sounds about right to me.  I see him kind of like a younger Sugano.

Posted
29 minutes ago, Stratos said:

Is he really that much worse than Taira?

Good thing is he's been healthy and consistently throws lots of innings.  Could be the new Taillon, a decent pitcher to put up innings for you.  Reliable but not exciting.

I mean we have zero top of rotation right now which I do believe Taira has the potential to be and Itoh not so much.

Posted
42 minutes ago, Stratos said:

Is he really that much worse than Taira?

Good thing is he's been healthy and consistently throws lots of innings.  Could be the new Taillon, a decent pitcher to put up innings for you.  Reliable but not exciting.

 The upside on Itoh is quite low. It's like "best case scenario he's a decent 4" but more than likely he's a nailed-on #5 who you never let start a playoff game. He's a low-velo guy with low whiff potential. Kind of the exact opposite you'd hope the Cubs would be done with. 

Taira's risk is a bit higher considering the workload questions but the upside is that of a mid-level #2 in a rotation. The fastball is both good (low arm slot and massive extension on 95mph) and bad (he has poor shape). The control is mediocre. But he also has a deep bag and big ground ball potential. Most likely a mid-rotation guy. Think a 3.

  • Like 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

I don't know why they're clogging up the 40 man with so much garbage 

At this point I’m thinking Jed’s just trying to get back at the fans for giving him so much sh*t. Like wtf trade is that lol

Posted
2 hours ago, Jason Ross said:

 The upside on Itoh is quite low. It's like "best case scenario he's a decent 4" but more than likely he's a nailed-on #5 who you never let start a playoff game. He's a low-velo guy with low whiff potential. Kind of the exact opposite you'd hope the Cubs would be done with. 

Taira's risk is a bit higher considering the workload questions but the upside is that of a mid-level #2 in a rotation. The fastball is both good (low arm slot and massive extension on 95mph) and bad (he has poor shape). The control is mediocre. But he also has a deep bag and big ground ball potential. Most likely a mid-rotation guy. Think a 3.

Yes the upside is low on Itoh.  But also similar NPB FIP/xFIPs and projections as Taira, who i agree is better. Itoh's not in any way exciting but could provide bulk innings if the FB holds up in MLB.  He's more a Rea/Taillon BORP type from a couple years ago, and will be cheap.

Taira i think is easy to overrate, besides the reliever risk my question is the secondaries for him.  I agree he's more likely a #3 but comes with #2 upside.

There's a bunch of names we've all been floating around like Holmes, King, even Taira, and if we're signing guys like that we may need innings from someone since these guys aren't known for eating innings.  Would prefer bulk innings from a much better SP like Rogers. but that also cost money and not often predictable.

Posted
Just now, Stratos said:

Yes the upside is low on Itoh.  But also similar NPB FIP/xFIPs and projections as Taira, who i agree is better. Itoh's not in any way exciting but could provide bulk innings if the FB holds up in MLB.  He's more a Rea/Taillon BORP type from a couple years ago, and will be cheap.

Taira i think is easy to overrate, besides the reliever risk my question is the secondaries for him.  I agree he's more likely a #3 but comes with #2 upside.

There's a bunch of names we've all been floating around like Holmes, King, even Taira, and if we're signing guys like that we may need innings from someone since these guys aren't known for eating innings.  Would prefer bulk innings from a much better SP like Rogers. but that also cost money and not often predictable.

What about his secondaries are you concerned about? There's more concern about fastball shape than anything there, to be fair.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

What about his secondaries are you concerned about? There's more concern about fastball shape than anything there, to be fair.

Yeah I watched Lance's recent breakdown on Taira and his FB with the larger MLB ball.  Just haven't heard a lot about the secondaries.   Sounds like he has average K potential.

Posted
Just now, Stratos said:

Yeah I watched Lance's recent breakdown on Taira and his FB with the larger MLB ball.  Just haven't heard a lot about the secondaries.   Sounds like he has average K potential.

Lance is more concerned than someone like Tread feels a bit differently based on this video  and talk about how shorter pitchers can maximize their fastball, through things like extension (Taira is elite at this) and low angles. Which I do think is important to note considering the connections.

It will be interesting to see how the fastball plays up. I do think he's got above average K% possibilities. His arm angle is funky and his extension adds velo. He has a deep bag of secondaries, though some are better than others. 

My biggest concern is:
1. Can someone with his background hold up?
2. Who's right on the fastball?

If Lance is right he's probably more mid-rotation, if Tread is closer to right there's a real chance he's more than that.

Posted

Taira is the most intriguing option for sure, but there's a ton of uncertainty there. I'm not sure how much more uncertainty the Cubs can afford on the SP front. It might be better to go with a boring guy like Gausman instead because you know what you're going to get.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...