Cubs Video
Given their other needs and the market that developed around him, the Cubs were never going to re-sign catcher Carson Kelly this winter. All along, their goal was to buy low on a player with a similarly balanced skill set, but with fewer bona fides and less earning power. They found such a backstop by claiming Joey Bart off waivers from the crosstown White Sox Friday, days after the South Siders had designated him for assignment.
Bart, who will turn 30 next month, was the second overall pick in the 2018 MLB Draft. He was taken by the Giants, and briefly, the organization dreamed on him becoming the heir to Buster Posey behind the plate. That never came to fruition. Bart struggled so mightily in parts of four seasons in the majors with San Francisco that he was shipped off unceremoniously to Pittsburgh in early 2024.
There, he briefly found some traction. Bart hit .265/.337/.462 in 282 plate appearances with the Pirates that year, and he's kept his on-base percentage above water ever since. However, that was the only real bust of brilliance he's shown in his career. In a bigger role in 2025, he maintained a .355 OBP but couldn't hold onto his power gains. He has plus bat speed, but whiffs too much to make the most of it, and mishits the ball more than a true all-or-nothing slugger, to boot.
Behind the plate, he's not a butcher, but nor is he a whiz. He's about average at controlling the running game and draws good reviews as a handler of pitching staffs, but he grades poorly as a pitch framer and didn't make good use of the ABS system in its first season. He bounced from the Pirates to the outskirts of Atlanta before finishing his season with the desperate White Sox; he was never going to stick around for long on the South Side.
This might also not be a long stop for Bart. This pickup is reminiscent of when the Cubs made a cash deal to acquire Matt Thais from the Angels two years ago to the day. Thaiss, too, was a very limited bat-first catcher who made sense on a roster that lacked a legitimate starting option, but the team agreed to sign Kelly less than a month later. Thaiss signed a split deal but ended up leaving the Cubs organization before ever playing for them.
Bart's chances of staying around are a bit better, because the team has more demands on its budget and fewer good alternatives this winter. They might be in a better position to let a veteran come to camp and take a part-time job early on, knowing that either Bart or Miguel Amaya could be easily jettisoned if needed once Owen Ayers is ready to debut.
This acquisition won't stop the team's hunt for a replacement for Kelly, but they can't afford to allocate many resources to the position, and they believe in Ayers enough to go into the coming season with a thinner catching corps than they usually would. Bart might be another quickly forgotten transient pitckup, or he might get 250 plate appearances for the 2027 Cubs. The team claimed him while he was in DFA limbo, but they've enfolded him into a new kind of limbo, for the time being.
Want to play the role of Cubs general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Cubs roster!
Build Your 2027 Roster




Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now