Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Replies 908
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
6 hours ago, Rcal10 said:

And if he did nothing several posters would be all over them for that. Also, had those guys won the Cubs something no one would have said a word about the lost assets. Whatever they gave up for Zeferjahn can’t be considered a waste of assets. They still have him. Can you even tell me who they gave up for Civale? The trade for Garrett really isn’t a waste of assets either. They have Garrett. So that brings us to Gausman and Holmes. Basically, the two best rentals picked up at the TDL. Yes, you have to trade something to get them. And, again, has they not you and others would be complaining about that. Basically it is whatever Jed does it is wrong, for some people. 

The guy put together a pitching staff that put up numbers in line with a 95-100 loss team, its not unreasonable to have zero faith in his ability to fill the many open spots in the rotation. A historic season by PCA, an elite defence, and elite offence couldn’t even get this team to 90 wins, thats how bad it was pitching wise. The english language does not have words capable of describing how bad it was. 

  • Like 3
Posted

BREAKING: The Colorado Rockies are acquiring right-handers Davis Martin and Luis Castillo in a trade with the Chicago White Sox, sources tell ESPN.  Rockies are taking on Castillo’s full salary. Two prospects are headed back to the White Sox.

Posted
3 hours ago, chibears55 said:

Why do you need to turn everything into an argument or disagreement,  my original post was simply nothing but saying how crazy something was. 

7 players, 6 pitchers,  2 returning so far, that the crazy part.

Dont know why you felt the need to make it anything more than that by defending the trades and all.

This is part of what i mentioned the other day, just feels like you need to make some kind of counter argument about everything I post lol

 

I’m not arguing with you. You gave your opinion and I gave mine. You think it is crazy to give away assets for rentals and I don’t agree. I think you have to trade for rentals or you will lose valuable assets, which aside from Rojas, the Cubs didn’t lose. Sorry if my opinion differs from your and that means we are arguing. We are just talking. I understand your POV and am fine with it. I just don’t agree. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Post Count Padder said:

I can't believe the White Sox got out from Castillo's contract that easily. 

I am sure the Rockies agreed to taking the entire contract so they can get Martin. I doubt the prospects amounted to much. Or at least the Sox got less back for Martin than they would have if they didn’t agree to take Castillo and his contract. I worry they money then Sox saved they will be players in pitchers the Cubs are interested in. 

Posted
1 hour ago, chibears55 said:

BREAKING: The Colorado Rockies are acquiring right-handers Davis Martin and Luis Castillo in a trade with the Chicago White Sox, sources tell ESPN.  Rockies are taking on Castillo’s full salary. Two prospects are headed back to the White Sox.

Wow, that is big news. Have to think the Sox have a pitcher in mind as a FA. My guess is Taira. But maybe Peralta. 

Posted
3 hours ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

The guy put together a pitching staff that put up numbers in line with a 95-100 loss team, its not unreasonable to have zero faith in his ability to fill the many open spots in the rotation. A historic season by PCA, an elite defence, and elite offence couldn’t even get this team to 90 wins, thats how bad it was pitching wise. The english language does not have words capable of describing how bad it was. 

They put most of their chips into the offense last offseason, thankfully that did pay off.

Unfortunately they went into the year with an average-ish at best pitching staff.  Three-fifths of their rotation had the worst years they could have possibly have had - Horton, Cabrera, and Taillon.  Ben Brown broke down.   The only thing that went their way was Shota bouncing back.

Some of that is how the staff was constructed (4 year deal for Taillon was always stupid), some of it is just bad luck.

I think Jed will probably do a solid job on pitching this offseason, how well he does is probably up to the market and how much WAR he can buy for ~75m.

  • Like 3
Posted
12 hours ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

The guy put together a pitching staff that put up numbers in line with a 95-100 loss team, its not unreasonable to have zero faith in his ability to fill the many open spots in the rotation. A historic season by PCA, an elite defence, and elite offence couldn’t even get this team to 90 wins, thats how bad it was pitching wise. The english language does not have words capable of describing how bad it was. 

You’re not wrong about the staff. But you are leaving out the fact that at one point an entire staff was on the IL. It was never going to be good, but it could/should have been 17-20 best based on WAR with normal health. That staff would have amounted to a team top 7-10 in runs allowed. Even with that awful staff and a ridiculous amount of injuries they Cubs were still around the middle if the pack in runs allowed. The FO doesn’t have to take this team from 30th in WAR to a top 10. If they can get it to 15-18 in WAR the Cubs will good at preventing runs. Which is the bottom line. I do feel there are enough fjys out there to accomplish this. Now, will Jed get the right guys. 

Posted
33 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

You’re not wrong about the staff. But you are leaving out the fact that at one point an entire staff was on the IL. It was never going to be good, but it could/should have been 17-20 best based on WAR with normal health. That staff would have amounted to a team top 7-10 in runs allowed. Even with that awful staff and a ridiculous amount of injuries they Cubs were still around the middle if the pack in runs allowed. The FO doesn’t have to take this team from 30th in WAR to a top 10. If they can get it to 15-18 in WAR the Cubs will good at preventing runs. Which is the bottom line. I do feel there are enough fjys out there to accomplish this. Now, will Jed get the right guys. 

Totally true, the injuries were ridiculous, I actually liked picking up Gausman and Holmes they just kinda turned into pumpkins unfortunately. I agree that a mid level staff is good enough, I just don’t know if he can the 15ish WAR to get there. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

Totally true, the injuries were ridiculous, I actually liked picking up Gausman and Holmes they just kinda turned into pumpkins unfortunately. I agree that a mid level staff is good enough, I just don’t know if he can the 15ish WAR to get there. 

I would be lying if I said I have all the confidence in the world this FO will get it done. But I do have all the confidence in the world that there are enough pitchers out there and the Cubs have enough money they can put towards those pitchers to get a staff that can be very good. They just need to pick the right ones and sign them. Hopefully they start soon. The Sox clearing Castillo off the books puts them in play for another top starter. That concerns me a little. I am hoping they go for King or Peralta, because I don’t think the Cubs will get them anyway.
My hope is 2 of Holmes, Gausman, Rogers, or Taira and then either Peterson, Soroka, Pivett(if healthy). There are a few others I am sure I can be ok with as well. I know if it turns out Gausman, Holmes and Peterson we are being the staff back. But I highly doubt it will work that way. And even if it did, those guys in the rotation all year should be better than the 30th best staff. 

Posted

Hopefully we see some actual transactions from the cubs today and or this weekend. 

Offers will or wont be tendered, we'll see what the Redsox will do with Duran as far as tender/trade or non tender him and he becomes a FA. 

Posted
34 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Hopefully we see some actual transactions from the cubs today and or this weekend. 

Offers will or wont be tendered, we'll see what the Redsox will do with Duran as far as tender/trade or non tender him and he becomes a FA. 

I wouldn’t mind Duran, either as a FA or as a low cost trade. Someone in the low minors. I know people want to point to last year on this guy, and it was really bad. But a change of scenery could get him to a guy who can replace Happ. Or, at the very least he could be a right handed platoon player. At $9-$11M I don’t see the Cubs getting a guy with more upside than Duran. And I don’t see them spending more than that for a bat. 

Posted
28 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I wouldn’t mind Duran, either as a FA or as a low cost trade. Someone in the low minors. I know people want to point to last year on this guy, and it was really bad. But a change of scenery could get him to a guy who can replace Happ. Or, at the very least he could be a right handed platoon player. At $9-$11M I don’t see the Cubs getting a guy with more upside than Duran. And I don’t see them spending more than that for a bat. 

Be nice if they got him and he gets back to what he was the 2-3 years before, a 20HR, 40 doubles, 20SB guy with an OPS mid 700 to 800

Posted

I would invite Duran in only if Bregman and the Cubs had a good idea he wasn't going to be an absolute cancer in the clubhouse. And I'll be honest, I'm not sure that's the case. The Cubs have a definitive vibe and while I think they can probably "fun it up" a bit (they do have a very "intense" vibe) Duran's ****** teammate and antagonistic behavior doesn't seem like a fit on the surface. 

I think you can find what Duran offers without the shittiness elsewhere. 

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

Yankees signed Loaisiga. Another top reliever off the board.

BTW, if the Sox sign Taira before Cubs make a move, I am out. Sox seem like they are actually making an attempt to be taken seriously.

Edited by Nolo
Posted
54 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Be nice if they got him and he gets back to what he was the 2-3 years before, a 20HR, 40 doubles, 20SB guy with an OPS mid 700 to 800

Yeah I mean even in 2026 season he was a 20-20 guy. It’s not a bad “floor”

Posted
Just now, Nolo said:

Yeah I mean even in 2026 season he was a 20-20 guy. It’s not a bad “floor”

He was the second worst qualified hitter in baseball last year

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Yeah I mean even in 2026 season he was a 20-20 guy. It’s not a bad “floor”

Half a win says opposite.

 

But this is a guy who had a 3-year run of 115+ so to bet on a bounce back does not seem too wild to me. 

Edited by We Got The Whole 9
Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, We Got The Whole 9 said:

Half a win says opposite.

But this is a guy who had a 3-year run of 115+ so to bet on a bounce back does not seem too wild to me. 

WAR is totally out of control at this point. He was 20-20 that’s the only point I made lol

Give me Duran, PCA, and Sato is the OF and we’re doing juuuuuust fine.

BTW, I was right about the Cubs getting their backup catcher as their first “real” move. Welcome Joey Bart.

Edited by Nolo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...