Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • 5 months later...
  • Replies 59
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Why would we ever need to go into tank mode? Epstein was revamping the organization from the ground up so that we would never have to tank again. That was the whole point, iirc.

 

 

plan failed? I don't know, unless we have some good prospects?

  • 4 months later...
Posted

I have been paying way too much attention to this team in the last few months than I should have given the W/L record.

 

Although I think Ross doesn't really do a great job of managing the pen, still, he is doing a pretty good job of keeping the players playing hard-to-win games. The current collection of AAAA players and veterans have played hard and appear to be invested in these games. I think that is a point in Ross's favor. I don't know that he is the guy you want managing a contender, but he's done a pretty good job with a very bad hand dealt to him.

Posted
I don't know that he is the guy you want managing a contender, but he's done a pretty good job with a very bad hand dealt to him.

 

Well he has job security for a few more years.

Posted
I don't know that he is the guy you want managing a contender, but he's done a pretty good job with a very bad hand dealt to him.

 

Well he has job security for a few more years.

I'm not a fan of a lot of your posts but I enjoyed this one. Well done.

  • 5 months later...
  • 2 months later...
Posted

There has to be a direct connection between Heyward upgrading Ross to a suite for every road trip in his last season and Ross' continually putting Heyward in the lineup right?

 

He has the lowest OPS+ of his career and is now a negative WAR player defensively (it's the same as Frazier, the most likely candidate to take his role and he's been terrible). I know its a small sample size but his age and track record don't exactly tell us that this has to be a fluke.

Posted
for me it's mainly a Jed problem, the smartest guy in the room can't find enough fault with a .615 OPS player last 2 seasons running to cut bait, so why would i place blame squarely on guy who can't effectively bake with rancid milk
Posted
May as well bring PCA up from High A and let him learn on the fly. There’s no way he could be worse.

Nelson Valasquez is murdering AAA pitching right now. There are probably multiple players in the minors who would produce at the same level as some of these dude.

Posted
The only way this made sense to me entering the season was that they valued Heyward's defense very highly, especially in CF since Happ is now a permanent LF. But with Suzuki's injury he can't be getting these reps, the RF defense/arm just isn't worth it when they clearly don't mind Ortega playing CF as well. He cannot catch up with velocity in the way a big league regular has to.
Old-Timey Member
Posted
The only way this made sense to me entering the season was that they valued Heyward's defense very highly, especially in CF since Happ is now a permanent LF. But with Suzuki's injury he can't be getting these reps, the RF defense/arm just isn't worth it when they clearly don't mind Ortega playing CF as well. He cannot catch up with velocity in the way a big league regular has to.

 

Yeah I think coming into the year I'd have bought that it was 50/50ish whether Heyward or Ortega were better suited to that LH platoon OF role. Heyward appeared to be the better defender, and while he was a mess last year was very strong in a platoon role from '18 - '20.

 

And with the mess that the 40 man was in due to all the injuries, as well as the 11 games in 9 days, I can buy why he actually made it off the IL. What I don't buy is why he's currently starting every day, or how/if he survives Seiya coming off the IL. Brett brought up the point of maybe out of respect they're giving him one final shot to turn it around? But again even doing as much mental gymnastics as possible it's essentially impossible to justify him making it to Monday.

Posted
The only way this made sense to me entering the season was that they valued Heyward's defense very highly, especially in CF since Happ is now a permanent LF. But with Suzuki's injury he can't be getting these reps, the RF defense/arm just isn't worth it when they clearly don't mind Ortega playing CF as well. He cannot catch up with velocity in the way a big league regular has to.

 

Yeah I think coming into the year I'd have bought that it was 50/50ish whether Heyward or Ortega were better suited to that LH platoon OF role. Heyward appeared to be the better defender, and while he was a mess last year was very strong in a platoon role from '18 - '20.

 

And with the mess that the 40 man was in due to all the injuries, as well as the 11 games in 9 days, I can buy why he actually made it off the IL. What I don't buy is why he's currently starting every day, or how/if he survives Seiya coming off the IL. Brett brought up the point of maybe out of respect they're giving him one final shot to turn it around? But again even doing as much mental gymnastics as possible it's essentially impossible to justify him making it to Monday.

The Cubs are experiencing the sunk cost fallacy.

Posted
Swear to god, there is a cut scene in The Show 22 after a big home run where everyone in the dugout is high fiving and Ross is standing there in the dugout with his hand in the air waiting for someone to give him some love and they are all ignoring him.
Posted
There has to be a direct connection between Heyward upgrading Ross to a suite for every road trip in his last season and Ross' continually putting Heyward in the lineup right?

 

He has the lowest OPS+ of his career and is now a negative WAR player defensively (it's the same as Frazier, the most likely candidate to take his role and he's been terrible). I know its a small sample size but his age and track record don't exactly tell us that this has to be a fluke.

 

Maybe Heyward got some of Ross's Squat Cobbler videos

  • 5 weeks later...
Posted
Ross and his staff and just about everyone else should be on the hot seat for this team's performance.

 

Ross was just extended, so he's a sunk cost. Maybe some coaches get fired to show that they're doing something

Posted
Ross and his staff and just about everyone else should be on the hot seat for this team's performance.

 

Ross was just extended, so he's a sunk cost. Maybe some coaches get fired to show that they're doing something

Considering the goal was to suck this season he seems to be getting exactly what the front office wanted from this team. They will suck again in 2023 and then can make a manager change before his final season under contract, when most managers get fired.

Posted
Ross and his staff and just about everyone else should be on the hot seat for this team's performance.

 

It will be really interesting to see how ownership handles the off-season assuming the remainder of the season goes the way it looks like it’s going to go.

 

You can’t put one of the worst teams in franchise history on the field and then not respond to it, right? If ownership was actually trying to win and actually cared about the product on the field, you’d fire some combination of Hoyer and Ross.

Posted
If ownership was actually trying to win and actually cared about the product on the field, you’d fire some combination of Hoyer and Ross.

Ownership is completely on board with the plan for this season, so nobody is going to get fired. Whatever you may think about Ross' in-game managerial skills, firing him would be a bad look. This team clearly has a roster problem more than a manager problem. My bigger concern is that I have zero trust in Hoyer to identify the right players once the team is ready to compete. His misses have been very concerning. I would prefer to move on from him sooner than later, but that simply isn't going to happen.

Posted
If ownership was actually trying to win and actually cared about the product on the field, you’d fire some combination of Hoyer and Ross.

Ownership is completely on board with the plan for this season, so nobody is going to get fired. Whatever you may think about Ross' in-game managerial skills, firing him would be a bad look. This team clearly has a roster problem more than a manager problem. My bigger concern is that I have zero trust in Hoyer to identify the right players once the team is ready to compete. His misses have been very concerning. I would prefer to move on from him sooner than later, but that simply isn't going to happen.

 

Yeah no one will be fired because the season was ultimately meaningless but the team turning out to be this bad is not a good look. It could ultimately hasten one of their departures if things continue this way for the next 1-2 seasons.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...