Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Replies 909
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
13 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

If Hoyer were to entertain this, it would cost probably 2 or 3 from this group of Wiggins, Ayers, Kepley, Hartshorn,  and Townsend for 2 years of Webb

Yeah I don't see it. Webb is still good but he's already shown signs of decline 

Posted
3 hours ago, chibears55 said:

They both had really good second halves and I think theyre more likely to return to being a 1-2 type starter then Gausman or Holmes.

Gausman, Holmes, or Petersen would be that 3rd guy for me if they get 2 of the 4 above.

 

You could be disappointed this offseason.  I'd be satisfied with Gausman or Holmes as our #2.  Peterson is more of a #3, but could play up on this team.

If we landed all 3 of them as our top 3 I wouldn't be jumping for joy, but it would be competent i guess.  Some age risk to live with.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

If you're buying Logan Webb you've gotta be damn sure you're buying low and a full rebound is on the way because the difference between 2026 Webb and what you'd expect out of David Peterson is like 3 points of walk rate.

  • Like 1
Verified Member
Posted (edited)
24 minutes ago, Stratos said:

You could be disappointed this offseason.  I'd be satisfied with Gausman or Holmes as our #2.  Peterson is more of a #3, but could play up on this team.

If we landed all 3 of them as our top 3 I wouldn't be jumping for joy, but it would be competent i guess.  Some age risk to live with.

Man losing our entire rotation to FA should be a blessing, a chance to rebuild it from the ground up, but if we end up just reverting back to par with Holmes, Gausman, and Peterson what a wasted opportunity. 

One of those guys, sure.

Edited by Nolo
Old-Timey Member
Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Man losing our entire rotation to FA should be a blessing, a chance to rebuild it from the ground up, but if we end up just reverting back to par with Holmes, Gausman, and Peterson what a wasted opportunity. 

One of those guys, sure.

A full year of Gausman, Holmes and Peterson and Cabrera being more what he was prior to his year with the Cubs is not bad for 4 guys in the rotation. If Steele and Garrett can hold down the last spot I wouldn’t mind that rotation. If/when Brown comes back that adds another good arm. Pen or starting. They also have Assad. With a healthy season, that staff could be mid level in WAR and top 10 in run prevention. 
That said, this wouldn’t be my ideal off season. My favorite would be Rogers, Taira and Holmes. 

Edited by Rcal10
Old-Timey Member
Posted
18 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Gausman is probably underrated at this point. All his under the hood numbers point to a rebound. He's way more of a sure bet than Taira.

True. But I don’t think they can get Rogers, Gausman and Holmes. Too much money. And Taira, while a risk, has a nice upside and can be under contract for 3 years or more. Gausman is probably a 1 year deal. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Stratos said:

You could be disappointed this offseason.  I'd be satisfied with Gausman or Holmes as our #2.  Peterson is more of a #3, but could play up on this team.

If we landed all 3 of them as our top 3 I wouldn't be jumping for joy, but it would be competent i guess.  Some age risk to live with.

I've been prepared to be underwhelmed this offseason with who they add.

Posted
2 hours ago, Rcal10 said:

A full year of Gausman, Holmes and Peterson and Cabrera being more what he was prior to his year with the Cubs is not bad for 4 guys in the rotation. If Steele and Garrett can hold down the last spot I wouldn’t mind that rotation. If/when Brown comes back that adds another good arm. Pen or starting. They also have Assad. With a healthy season, that staff could be mid level in WAR and top 10 in run prevention. 
That said, this wouldn’t be my ideal off season. My favorite would be Rogers, Taira and Holmes. 

What's depressing is that it would be almost an A+ offseason if we just  brought back everyone who is an FA including Seiya/Happ (and Kelly/Conforto).

Blowing the #1 wildcard seed and losing home field advantage was a disaster. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted

I'd be shocked if Holmes isn't back.  I'd consider him to be the single most likely move this winter, lotta smoke in that direction.

Old-Timey Member
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Derwood said:

I’m not a fan of the “bring back the same chumps but hope for better results” approach to the off season

It wouldn’t be my first choice. But from a pitching standpoint Gausman, Holmes and Peterson in the rotation all year would most likely move the Cubs from 30th to closer to middle of the pack, if ‘27 has a normal amount of injuries. I want Rogers instead of Gausman and Taira instead of  Peterson. Rogers, because I want more than a 1 year signing. And Taira because I would like to take a chance on upside, and keep the Japanese market flowing. 
Another guy wouldn’t mind taking a chance on his upside is Soroka. I think the Cubs were early on him in ‘25, but if he can stay healthy he could give solid #3 production. Could do a lot worse as the 3rd pitcher they sign.

But on that note; let’s get one soon. 

Edited by Rcal10
Posted
12 hours ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Gausman is probably underrated at this point. All his under the hood numbers point to a rebound. He's way more of a sure bet than Taira.

He cant just be a 4 seam/splitter guy. They need to get his slider back.

Posted
11 hours ago, Stratos said:

What's depressing is that it would be almost an A+ offseason if we just  brought back everyone who is an FA including Seiya/Happ (and Kelly/Conforto).

Blowing the #1 wildcard seed and losing home field advantage was a disaster. 

Yeah lets just run back a bottom three pitching staff in baseball and hope we can miraculously score our way out of 100 losses. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

Yeah lets just run back a bottom three pitching staff in baseball and hope we can miraculously score our way out of 100 losses. 

 

1 hour ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

They won 89 games with a ridiculous amount of injuries. Why would they lose 100 bringing back guys that were only here for 1/3 of the season? With health and Holmes, Gausman and Peterson, I would expect the teams WAR to be closer to 15-18 in the league. Added to the defense they play, it would make them a top 7-10 in run prevention. While I do not advocate bringing those exact 3 guys back, I think your assessment of the staff being one that could lose 100 games is way overboard. 

Edited by Rcal10
Posted

This thread is playing out like an extended game thread where the Cubs are losing by 2 going into the bottom of the 7th and the offense is playing like crap.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, Outshined_One said:

This thread is playing out like an extended game thread where the Cubs are losing by 2 going into the bottom of the 7th and the offense is playing like crap.

This is what happens when the fanbase starts to get antsy and wants the Cubs to make a move. You get a lot of angry people exaggerating .

They have a lot to do this off season. At the very least they probably have to add 5 more players. 3 pitchers and 2 hitters. With the lock out the off season is going to be shortened. So the FO does need to wake up and start getting things done. Needing 3 pitchers is a tall task. They can do it. But with other teams needing pitching too, I would rather not wait and just take whoever falls.

Verified Member
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, Rcal10 said:

It wouldn’t be my first choice. But from a pitching standpoint Gausman, Holmes and Peterson in the rotation all year would most likely move the Cubs from 30th to closer to middle of the pack, if ‘27 has a normal amount of injuries. I want Rogers instead of Gausman and Taira instead of  Peterson. Rogers, because I want more than a 1 year signing. And Taira because I would like to take a chance on upside, and keep the Japanese market flowing. 
Another guy wouldn’t mind taking a chance on his upside is Soroka. I think the Cubs were early on him in ‘25, but if he can stay healthy he could give solid #3 production. Could do a lot worse as the 3rd pitcher they sign.

But on that note; let’s get one soon. 

okay good, so you too don’t want to bring a Gausman/Holmes/Peterson rotation.

We can talk ourselves into anything but how far did those three guys get us last season?

Rogers/Taira/Soroka it is.

We deserve better 

Edit: that said, Holmes and Peterson in addition to Rogers and Taira, sign me the F up. 

Edited by Nolo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...