Jump to content
North Side Baseball

Week 10: Bears (3-5) @ Packers (5-3) 7:30PM NBC/780


Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Replies 727
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
At the beginning of the year someone had the Bears last in the North something like 6-10. I was incredulous. Still having trouble grasping what the hell happened here

 

no depth of talent and poor coaching

Posted
This has got to be IT. The worst single game embarrassment in Bears history

Honest question: Does McCarthy have one eye on 73-0 at this point?

Sure. Don't cost nothin

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

That's the same [expletive] defense that hendry lived on for a decade.

 

Emery has been awful.

Posted
This has got to be IT. The worst single game embarrassment in Bears history

Honest question: Does McCarthy have one eye on 73-0 at this point?

 

That briefly crossed my mind. But he would be hanged if Rodgers got hurt

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Jason Campbell, Lamar Houston and Michael Bush say hello.

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

That's the same [expletive] defense that hendry lived on for a decade.

 

Emery has been awful.

I can't argue he's not awful because the results speak for themselves.

 

If we're comparing him to Hendry though I think Hendry actually had the ability to set the franchise back beyond his tenure. I don't see that with Emery because at worst I do believe he'll improve our talent base. But the coaching decision can be remedied immediately at whatever point you want to move on.

 

Now granted it would be better to move on in 2014 rather than waiting til 2015 until you remember it's still Philips who will be making that replacement. Toss up as to what he'll find IMO.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Jason Campbell, Lamar Houston and Michael Bush say hello.

Lamar Houston played his role well. Bush and Campbell are not significant in the entirety of his FA record.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

 

That's the same [expletive] defense that hendry lived on for a decade.

 

Emery has been awful.

I can't argue he's not awful because the results speak for themselves.

 

If we're comparing him to Hendry though I think Hendry actually had the ability to set the franchise back beyond his tenure. I don't see that with Emery because at worst I do believe he'll improve our talent base. But the coaching decision can be remedied immediately at whatever point you want to move on.

 

Now granted it would be better to move on in 2014 rather than waiting til 2015 until you remember it's still Philips who will be making that replacement. Toss up as to what he'll find IMO.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That is only because of the nature of MLB vs NFL rosters, the latter of which do not take 3 years to improve. Of course, that is also only true if you stupidly believe the Cubs roster couldn't have been better the last 3 years if somebody actually tried to make them better.

 

 

Hendry didn't set the team back. He failed to win enough when they were capable of winning. He has nothing to do with the past 3 years.

Posted
Has Emery been good?

 

His FA record has been mediocre at best as well as the draft.

 

He's been GM for 3 years and this team is awful. It's pretty clear he has not been good.

He's largely done well with talent composition IMO. He inherited an aging defensive team and outside of his first draft where he still managed to draft a pro-bowl caliber WR, I think has done well drafting. His only real bad FA signing to this point is JA. And his one trade was great

 

At this juncture his coaching decisions have completely undermined those things(literally half of today's scores can be linked directly to coaching not talent). So yes he's been bad, but I don't think it's unreasonable if you liked him at first you'd give him a shot to correct this current existing weakness.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Jason Campbell, Lamar Houston and Michael Bush say hello.

Lamar Houston played his role well. Bush and Campbell are not significant in the entirety of his FA record.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Much like having Aaron Rodgers can cover a multitude of GM sins, fantastically failing your HC hire can hide many other decent GM moves.

Posted
omg this broadcast is nothing but stupid shoutouts to GB lore

 

 

@Bro_Pair: Lombardi Avenue looks like it's in Pyongyang

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...