Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Replies 482
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

3-0 Braves still, now in bottom of 7th.

 

Also, glad I'm not a MLB'er so I can go spelunking whenever I want.

 

If you're not watching WGN feed, LenBob is having an odd conversation about prohibited activity clauses in player contracts.

Guest
Guests
Posted
Geo to the opposite field again. I love it.
Posted
of course santo belongs in the hall, his numbers are far better than brooks robinson's yet brooks is a first-ballot guy. his glove was in the ballpark as well.

 

from every account i've read, brooks robinson is the best defensive 3B of all time. santo was very good but not great.

 

still, it's pointless in arguing between the two of them because they both clearly belong in the hall of fame.

 

i never said that santo was as good, just in the ballpark. and ronnie's offensive superiority exceeds robinson's defensive superiority. robinson played on winning teams and had longevity on his side, but santo was just a much better hitter and usually that's what gets people into the hall.

 

I've made this post before, but here goes about Santo in the HOF.

 

Right now the HOF lists 13 players that have been inducted primarily as 3B. Three of those were inducted from the Negro Leagues.

 

If Santo were added to the other ten, there would be eleven third basemen in the HOF. So, how would he rank among these other greats? In other words, I wanted to answer the question if Santo would lower the quality of player in the HOF.

 

Here's what I came up with.

 

Santo's 342 homeruns would rank him third among HOF thirdbasemen behind only 500 HR club members Mike Schmidt and Eddie Matthews.

 

Santo's 1331 RBI would rank him fourth among the current HOF third sackers.

 

His .277 BA might be one of the knocks on him as six of the ten HOF third basemen have hit over 300. However, there still would be four HOF thirdbasemen with lower batting averages.

 

Santo has five Gold Gloves. Only two HOF thirdbasemen (Schmidt and Robinson) have more, and six have none.

 

Santo's 954 Fielding % ranks him at sixth would be middle of the pack.

 

Santo scored 1138 runs which places him in the middle of the pack at fifth.

 

His 362 OBP would rank him sixth and his 464 SLG would rank him fourth.

 

Finally, his OPS+ of 125 would rank him fifth and his 324 Win Shares would be fifth on the list as well.

 

There's not a single category that would rank him in the lower third. Most metrics place him squarely in the middle of the pack among HOF thirdbasemen.

 

The case is clear that Santo belongs and there really shouldn't be any argument.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
For those of you not in the AIM chat, Miguel Olivo got plunked in the Royals/Sox game, charged the mound and incited a bench-clearer. Got a piece of AJ Pierzynski in the process.
Posted
Geo to the opposite field again. I love it.

 

yup he is making the adjustment now... just took a little time. pitchers are gonna realize that he's not going to keep trying to pull breaking balls on the outer half of the plate, and they'll have to throw him more fastballs. he's a good hitter, but still learning.

Posted
For those of you not in the AIM chat, Miguel Olivo got plunked in the Royals/Sox game, charged the mound and incited a bench-clearer. Got a piece of AJ Pierzynski in the process.

 

Always a good decision.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

The case is clear that Santo belongs and there really shouldn't be any argument.

 

Does anyone really make an argument about Santo's worthiness, or do they just vote against him because of the 40 year old grudge?

 

I think it's the latter, because I never hear a convincing argument that shows Santo shouldn't be in.

Posted
3-0 Braves still, now in bottom of 7th.

 

Also, glad I'm not a MLB'er so I can go spelunking whenever I want.

 

If you're not watching WGN feed, LenBob is having an odd conversation about prohibited activity clauses in player contracts.

 

they don't want their players contracting rabies.

Posted
3-0 Braves still, now in bottom of 7th.

 

Also, glad I'm not a MLB'er so I can go spelunking whenever I want.

 

If you're not watching WGN feed, LenBob is having an odd conversation about prohibited activity clauses in player contracts.

 

they don't want their players contracting rabies.

 

Can you imagine Aaron Harang with rabies?

 

:-k

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...