Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted (edited)
12 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I’m calling it now, Cubs are signing one of Peralta or King. 

No Peralta, please, unless it's a 2yr deal.  I don't even know if I want King.  

Edited by mk49
  • Replies 909
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted (edited)

I’m fascinated by the Cubs philosophy of spending $250 million to money ball their way into winning as many games as the Guadians by stacking the roster with 1 to 2 war vets until they exceed the LT. 

Edited by Geographyhater8888
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Geographyhater8888 said:

I’m fascinated by the Cubs philosophy of spending $250 million to money ball your way into winning as many games as the Guadians by stacking as many 1.5 to 2 war vets as the payroll permits. 

My biggest ick with Hoyer, he avoids going for the HR and settles for the single/double type players.

It may work over 162 game schedule but we've seen how it doesn't in the postseason, when not having a top SP or two, or quality high leverage relievers, it gets exposed by a solid playoff lineup.

Bats over 162 may be able to overcome cold spells and get hot at times, but in October when they start facing pitchers with high velocities and a tighter strike zone, its hasn't been easy for them to string a few hits together, over having that guy who can get that big HR for them in middle of lineup.

Having a bunch of 2 war players is cool over 162 but you need a couple of those 6+ war studs that could take over series in October. 

They need to add onto PCA not around him

 

Edited by chibears55
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
45 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

My biggest ick with Hoyer, he avoids going for the HR and settles for the single/double type players.

It may work over 162 game schedule but we've seen how it doesn't in the postseason, when not having a top SP or two, or quality high leverage relievers, it gets exposed by a solid playoff lineup.

Bats over 162 may be able to overcome cold spells and get hot at times, but in October when they start facing pitchers with high velocities and a tighter strike zone, its hasn't been easy for them to string a few hits together, over having that guy who can get that big HR for them in middle of lineup.

Having a bunch of 2 war players is cool over 162 but you need a couple of those 6+ war studs that could take over series in October. 

They need to add onto PCA not around him

 

They were third in all of baseball with 220 homers. Power isn’t their issue, or at least wasn’t with Happ and Suzuki. 20-25 home run power pull hitters with safe defensive floors is the theme. Jeds love for double digit velocity and safe arms has been more of a problem than a clumpy scoring offense with great rate stats.

Edited by Geographyhater8888
  • Like 1
Posted
1 hour ago, chibears55 said:

My biggest ick with Hoyer, he avoids going for the HR and settles for the single/double type players.

It may work over 162 game schedule but we've seen how it doesn't in the postseason, when not having a top SP or two, or quality high leverage relievers, it gets exposed by a solid playoff lineup.

Bats over 162 may be able to overcome cold spells and get hot at times, but in October when they start facing pitchers with high velocities and a tighter strike zone, its hasn't been easy for them to string a few hits together, over having that guy who can get that big HR for them in middle of lineup.

Having a bunch of 2 war players is cool over 162 but you need a couple of those 6+ war studs that could take over series in October. 

They need to add onto PCA not around him

 

The offence is not the problem. League average pitching last year and they probably win the division. Its astonishing that they won 89 games with that staff. 

Posted
39 minutes ago, Geographyhater8888 said:

They were third in all of baseball with 220 homers. Power isn’t their issue, or at least wasn’t with Happ and Suzuki. 20-25 home run power pull hitters with safe defensive floors is the theme. Jeds love for double digit velocity and safe arms has been more of a problem than a clumpy scoring offense with great rate stats.

Pitching has definitely been the bigger issue, but yea over 162 they generated power but during the playoffs they struggled offensively.

The Happ and Suzuki are fine, just need more than 1 PCA to surround them. Lol

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

The offence is not the problem. League average pitching last year and they probably win the division. Its astonishing that they won 89 games with that staff. 

As I mentioned, the offense during 162 works, but in a playoff series, not so much as we seen.

Maybe im just being greedy or whatever but, i just feel they would be better if they had another stud bat or two, in that lineup with PCA that could be counted on to carry a team if needed in a playoff series, over having 8 make or break guys, if you get what im saying 

Edited by chibears55
Posted (edited)
34 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Pitching has definitely been the bigger issue, but yea over 162 they generated power but during the playoffs they struggled offensively.

The Happ and Suzuki are fine, just need more than 1 PCA to surround them. Lol

Suzuki posted a 134, Bregman posted a 128, PCA posted a 157. That’s as potent as it gets. The 3 of them recording 1 combined hit in the playoffs is something no GM can forecast. Shuffling through which number 4 starter to pitch in game one of a best of series, because Taillon, Boyd and Imanaga are your highest paid pitchers is where Jed is at fault. 
 

Maybe the travel schedule horsefeathered with them Flying to Boston, Tampa and San Diego in a span of. 3 days.

Edited by Geographyhater8888
Posted
42 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

As I mentioned, the offense during 162 works, but in a playoff series, not so much as we seen.

Maybe im just being greedy or whatever but, i just feel they would be better if they had another stud bat or two, in that lineup with PCA that could be counted on to carry a team if needed in a playoff series, over having 8 make or break guys, if you get what im saying 

They do kinda have an issue of lineup construction with the whole “one guy goes cold and the entire offence falls off a cliff” thing, but theres no point doing anything to improve the lineup if the pitching isn’t massively improved. Intangibly I think part of the reason the hitting struggled later in the year and playoffs was the morale effect among the batters caused by knowing they had to drag the massive boat anchor that was  a bunch of amateurs on the staff. 

Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

They do kinda have an issue of lineup construction with the whole “one guy goes cold and the entire offence falls off a cliff” thing, but theres no point doing anything to improve the lineup if the pitching isn’t massively improved. Intangibly I think part of the reason the hitting struggled later in the year and playoffs was the morale effect among the batters caused by knowing they had to drag the massive boat anchor that was  a bunch of amateurs on the staff. 

It’s pitching they need. They had the best offense and defense in baseball and only made the WC. Any team can slump. They picked a bad time to not hit. 

Edited by Rcal10
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

The thing that gives me hope about Morejon, or any high leverage bullpen arm ie Soto, is the fact that the Cubs offered Tanner Scott 4/66M a couple years ago. They are willing to spend on a dominant closer type if they love the player. 

Another reason I really like Taira over someone like Itoh — let’s say Brown and Horton come back as starters and are healthy, whether it’s 2027 or 2028 or the playoffs, Taira can be confidently moved into high leverage bullpen role. I’d probably pick Taira over Morejon/Soto for that flexibility if it was one or the other.

Guys like Garrett and Assad are simply not bullpen weapons.

Edited by Nolo
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

They do kinda have an issue of lineup construction with the whole “one guy goes cold and the entire offence falls off a cliff” thing, but theres no point doing anything to improve the lineup if the pitching isn’t massively improved. Intangibly I think part of the reason the hitting struggled later in the year and playoffs was the morale effect among the batters caused by knowing they had to drag the massive boat anchor that was  a bunch of amateurs on the staff. 

Im not disagreeing that pitching was and is the bigger and main issue.

Yes that needs to be addressed and set before any lineup construction. 

I was just combining both as something id like to see upgraded going forward, having a couple more above average players over a bunch of average types. 

Also just to bring up, yes the offense put up good production during the season, just wanna add, are we sure itll be just as good or better with Bart over Kelly, and possibly players like Duran, or Shaw/Ramirez platoon types replacing Happ and Suzuki?

Sato likely becomes a bigger target to get, he'll at least provide the power production that Suzuki had

 

Edited by chibears55
Posted
13 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Im not disagreeing that pitching was and is the bigger and main issue.

Yes that needs to be addressed and set before any lineup construction. 

I was just combining both as something id like to see upgraded going forward, having a couple more above average players over a bunch of average types. 

Also just to bring up, yes the offense put up good production during the season, just wanna add, are we sure itll be just as good or better with Bart over Kelly, and possibly players like Duran, or Shaw/Ramirez platoon types replacing Happ and Suzuki?

Sato likely becomes a bigger target to get, he'll at least provide the power production that Suzuki had

 

I agree the offense will be worse. While I think they can make up for the Happ loss with a solid platoon, loosing Suzuki and Kelly is going to be hard to make up. But it still can be a top 5 offense with decent bats picked up. They aren’t going to spend big there. The hope is the pitching goes from maybe 30th in WAR to 15-20th. With the defense they play that would probably put them in the top 10 in run prevention. That should be another good team and another good season. 

Posted (edited)

Out of the signings so far, I like McDermott. I don’t think the Mets truly wanted to lose him I think they were trying to sneak him through waivers by giving him a big league contract days before. Jed snatched up. But man if they can figure out his command he could have some value 

Edited by Nolo
Posted
5 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I agree the offense will be worse. While I think they can make up for the Happ loss with a solid platoon, loosing Suzuki and Kelly is going to be hard to make up. But it still can be a top 5 offense with decent bats picked up. They aren’t going to spend big there. The hope is the pitching goes from maybe 30th in WAR to 15-20th. With the defense they play that would probably put them in the top 10 in run prevention. That should be another good team and another good season. 

That my biggest concern now, and why I dont care to see certain names being floated around for them with pitchers. Yes, itll improve from what they got last season but will it be enough to overcome what they might lose offensively. 

Obviously better production from a couple guys that had down years like Busch will help, just hope whomever they add can be at least close to what they lost.

Skubal would be a nice surprise,  but in reality id like to see them get two of...

Rogers, King, Taira, or Peralta 

At least those guys can or have potential to be solid 1-2 type starters

Posted
1 hour ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

They do kinda have an issue of lineup construction with the whole “one guy goes cold and the entire offence falls off a cliff” thing, but theres no point doing anything to improve the lineup if the pitching isn’t massively improved. Intangibly I think part of the reason the hitting struggled later in the year and playoffs was the morale effect among the batters caused by knowing they had to drag the massive boat anchor that was  a bunch of amateurs on the staff. 

How is that a lineup construction issue? 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
27 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

That my biggest concern now, and why I dont care to see certain names being floated around for them with pitchers. Yes, itll improve from what they got last season but will it be enough to overcome what they might lose offensively. 

Obviously better production from a couple guys that had down years like Busch will help, just hope whomever they add can be at least close to what they lost.

Skubal would be a nice surprise,  but in reality id like to see them get two of...

Rogers, King, Taira, or Peralta 

At least those guys can or have potential to be solid 1-2 type starters

I agree I want to see 2 higher end pitchers, but I think you are using prior bias on Peralta and King to suggest they are good. Last year each dropped. King and Peralta really don’t have very good savant pages. I think they can get two good pitchers without having to sign either of them. Taira, Rogers, Gausman and Holmes would be who I would like to see 2 of 4 from. Then still get a solid MOR starter as the 3rd signing. 

Posted
1 hour ago, chibears55 said:

Im not disagreeing that pitching was and is the bigger and main issue.

Yes that needs to be addressed and set before any lineup construction. 

I was just combining both as something id like to see upgraded going forward, having a couple more above average players over a bunch of average types. 

Also just to bring up, yes the offense put up good production during the season, just wanna add, are we sure itll be just as good or better with Bart over Kelly, and possibly players like Duran, or Shaw/Ramirez platoon types replacing Happ and Suzuki?

Sato likely becomes a bigger target to get, he'll at least provide the power production that Suzuki had

 

Expecting offensive regression is exactly why I desperately want them to fix the pitching. If the offensive production isn’t top 5 in baseball and the pitching doesn’t get leagues better, the Cubs will lose 95-100 games. 

  • Like 1
Verified Member
Posted
22 minutes ago, Gjfificifjdej said:

Expecting offensive regression is exactly why I desperately want them to fix the pitching. If the offensive production isn’t top 5 in baseball and the pitching doesn’t get leagues better, the Cubs will lose 95-100 games. 

exactly this 

Verified Member
Posted (edited)

I’m super curious of how many FA will be left after Dec. 2

Edited by Nolo
Posted
18 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I agree I want to see 2 higher end pitchers, but I think you are using prior bias on Peralta and King to suggest they are good. Last year each dropped. King and Peralta really don’t have very good savant pages. I think they can get two good pitchers without having to sign either of them. Taira, Rogers, Gausman and Holmes would be who I would like to see 2 of 4 from. Then still get a solid MOR starter as the 3rd signing. 

They both had really good second halves and I think theyre more likely to return to being a 1-2 type starter then Gausman or Holmes.

Gausman, Holmes, or Petersen would be that 3rd guy for me if they get 2 of the 4 above.

 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Nolo said:

I’m super curious of how many FA will be left after Dec. 2

a lot of bad ones, most of the good ones will be gone

there will likely be a huge flurry of activity right before midnight

Edited by Tangled Up in Plaid

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...