Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted
1 hour ago, Nolo said:

Man this makes me sad. Feel like Cubs are being cheated on (although I feel like I have to disclose that I know its not the case). Seiya going to fall in love with San Diego and you know he remembers that playoff atmosphere.

 

 

27 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Which one of you will be a Cub?

savant-comparison-tool (3).png

These two posts in succession are such a bummer.

  • Like 1
  • Replies 671
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Verified Member
Posted
1 minute ago, Bobson Dugnutt said:

These two posts in succession are such a bummer.

It's looking bleak.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, Bertz said:

holy horsefeathers

Takes a Seattle trade for a pitcher off the table (if it was actually a possibility). 

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Matt Shaw projects as a similar hitter to Garcia, and depending on how much you want to take from his defensive performance in the 2H of 2025 might not be that far behind.  Shaw's under control for the same amount of time, and at pre arb/arb salaries instead of Garcia's extension.

The error bars are wider on Shaw, notably he does not have a 5.5 win season on his resume, but I would presume a similar deal could have been done with him. 

North Side Contributor
Posted
12 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Matt Shaw projects as a similar hitter to Garcia, and depending on how much you want to take from his defensive performance in the 2H of 2025 might not be that far behind.  Shaw's under control for the same amount of time, and at pre arb/arb salaries instead of Garcia's extension.

The error bars are wider on Shaw, notably he does not have a 5.5 win season on his resume, but I would presume a similar deal could have been done with him. 

Probably. And I'll say this: I think the Cubs can aim higher than Bryce Miller. Like are we even sure he's good? He's been a 4.82 ERA (4.36 xERA and 4.23 xFIP) over his last two seasons (~200 IP). 

I think Bryce Miller is probably better than that, but I am not very certain. I'm fine with the Cubs finding a slightly better version of Miller. 

Verified Member
Posted

Goodbye any shot of Gilbert, Kirby, Woo, or Hancock. Was fun to dream.

Anyways, another catcher rumor/option. Bleak...

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Goodbye any shot of Gilbert, Kirby, Woo, or Hancock. Was fun to dream.

Anyways, another catcher rumor/option. Bleak...

 

I really think too much time is being used on discussing the cubs spending $3M-$4M on a back up catcher. To me, it is far down the priorities of the off season. Just sign or trade for someone. Not a big deal. But they do need to start getting other things in order. Nice to get a few pieces before the lock out. Back up catcher is not one I care about. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

Probably. And I'll say this: I think the Cubs can aim higher than Bryce Miller. Like are we even sure he's good? He's been a 4.82 ERA (4.36 xERA and 4.23 xFIP) over his last two seasons (~200 IP). 

I think Bryce Miller is probably better than that, but I am not very certain. I'm fine with the Cubs finding a slightly better version of Miller. 

Yeah Miller's got some upside but he is not any better than what you can nab on the FA market, and is only two years to FA.  This is not a Kirby or a Gilbert talent or a long term rotation fill.  I would not have done this unless money is much tighter than we expect.

Verified Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I really think too much time is being used on discussing the cubs spending $3M-$4M on a back up catcher. To me, it is far down the priorities of the off season. Just sign or trade for someone. Not a big deal. But they do need to start getting other things in order. Nice to get a few pieces before the lock out. Back up catcher is not one I care about. 

Watch backup catcher be the first move they make 😆 But yeah okay enough dumpster diving talk.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, Nolo said:

Watch backup catcher be the first move they make 😆 But yeah okay enough dumpster diving talk.

You’re probably right. And I get the talk. Sadly it is the only thing we hear right now. Just saying, I hope soon to be talking about moves that matter. 

North Side Contributor
Posted

I know we're all impatient, and with the impending lockout, I think it's probably a bit exacerbated, but most of the Cubs' offseasons follow a pretty common pattern:
- The Cubs start with some MiLB/small additions (fans get super snarky about it)
- The Cubs add an legit MLB player on a shorter-term deal (fans get confused)
- The Cubs get serious and make their big additions

The Cubs have a lot of shopping to do, but I would expect they have to add 2-3 MLB players before the lockout. FCT looked at the last lockout and most of the 2+ fWAR pitchers signed pre-lockout. The Cubs are likely going to be prepared to hit that market with a few pickups shortly. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
5 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

I know we're all impatient, and with the impending lockout, I think it's probably a bit exacerbated, but most of the Cubs' offseasons follow a pretty common pattern:
- The Cubs start with some MiLB/small additions (fans get super snarky about it)
- The Cubs add an legit MLB player on a shorter-term deal (fans get confused)
- The Cubs get serious and make their big additions

The Cubs have a lot of shopping to do, but I would expect they have to add 2-3 MLB players before the lockout. FCT looked at the last lockout and most of the 2+ fWAR pitchers signed pre-lockout. The Cubs are likely going to be prepared to hit that market with a few pickups shortly. 

🤞

Posted
6 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

I know we're all impatient, and with the impending lockout, I think it's probably a bit exacerbated, but most of the Cubs' offseasons follow a pretty common pattern:
- The Cubs start with some MiLB/small additions (fans get super snarky about it)
- The Cubs add an legit MLB player on a shorter-term deal (fans get confused)
- The Cubs get serious and make their big additions

The Cubs have a lot of shopping to do, but I would expect they have to add 2-3 MLB players before the lockout. FCT looked at the last lockout and most of the 2+ fWAR pitchers signed pre-lockout. The Cubs are likely going to be prepared to hit that market with a few pickups shortly. 

Also every year after Jed's first they have add someone who was worth 3+ WAR the year before

21-22: Stroman

22-23: Swanson

23-24: Bellinger

24-25: Tucker

25-26: Bregman

  • Love 1
North Side Contributor
Posted
3 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Also every year after Jed's first they have add someone who was worth 3+ WAR the year before

21-22: Stroman

22-23: Swanson

23-24: Bellinger

24-25: Tucker

25-26: Bregman

A lot of times it isn't the player we expect, either. Like we went into 24/25 expecting maybe a pitcher and they came away with Tucker. Same last year with Bregman. In retrospect both made sense, but it wasn't someone had on the Bingo Card day 1 of the offseason. With a truncated offseason, I suspect that the Cubs may make that move pre-lockout as opposed to post to be done with it, but there is usually one or two surprises in a Jed offseason. 

I can be honest and say that the messaging is making me a little concerned, and that I think almost regardless of what happens I'll find some disappointment in the organization's refusal to treat themselves and actually attack the market for a true star player, but that I'm also not worried that the team is punting or going to cobble together some nothing burger or a team. There's probably one fun surprise in there.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

I'm guessing Peterson is the first signing, seems like such a no brainer at his price point.

Of course, this is assuming we know his price point. If it is $12-$13M annual and no more than 2 years, I agree. But we just don’t know. What happens if he gets up to the guaranteed 3 year deal and it is pushing $42M? Or 2/$28 with a 3rd year option of $14 more? Do they sign him? Not so sure they do, or should. 

Posted
2 hours ago, Bertz said:

Yeah Miller's got some upside but he is not any better than what you can nab on the FA market, and is only two years to FA.  This is not a Kirby or a Gilbert talent or a long term rotation fill.  I would not have done this unless money is much tighter than we expect.

Isn't that the whole point though? We can't get any better than Miller on the FA market for Miller's salary. That's the value of it all. The fact that we need to commit 8 digits annually to multiple mid rotation starters is the cited reason as to why we can't/won't/shouldn't go after the Skubals and Seiyas of the world. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...