Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted

Decided to play around and do a little math this afternoon while I stay green on Teams.

Below is the YoY correlation for various pitching stats between 2025 and 2026.  I used all pitchers with 50 IP in both years, which should reduce noise but admittedly may also introduce some survivor bias.  Anyways:

BABIP - 26.7%

LOB% - 10.9%

GB% - 74.5%

HR/FB rate - 8.7% (*clears throat*)

ERA - 31.2%

xERA - 50.0%

FIP - 47.6%

xFIP - 64.4% (*even louder throat clearing*)

K% - 74.8%

BB% - 59.3%

Average Exit Velo - 55.4%

Barrel Rate - 39.5%

Hard Hit Rate - 49.5%

If you're ever wondering "why the horsefeathers won't this guy shut up about xFIP" this is the type of evidence that compels my obstinance.

  • Replies 909
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
2 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

1 more hour on these tenders decisions 

 

cubs always have to make sure they are the last to announce anything at deadlines 

Posted

I’d take this OF all day if it means they can sign Morejon.

LF - Duran

CF - PCA

RF - Shaw/Larnach platoon

Posted
26 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Decided to play around and do a little math this afternoon while I stay green on Teams.

Below is the YoY correlation for various pitching stats between 2025 and 2026.  I used all pitchers with 50 IP in both years, which should reduce noise but admittedly may also introduce some survivor bias.  Anyways:

BABIP - 26.7%

LOB% - 10.9%

GB% - 74.5%

HR/FB rate - 8.7% (*clears throat*)

ERA - 31.2%

xERA - 50.0%

FIP - 47.6%

xFIP - 64.4% (*even louder throat clearing*)

K% - 74.8%

BB% - 59.3%

Average Exit Velo - 55.4%

Barrel Rate - 39.5%

Hard Hit Rate - 49.5%

If you're ever wondering "why the horsefeathers won't this guy shut up about xFIP" this is the type of evidence that compels my obstinance.

Bertz, please excuse my ignorance. But what do these numbers represent? I have looked at this several times and clueless to what this means. And would really like to know. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Rcal10 said:

Bertz, please excuse my ignorance. But what do these numbers represent? I have looked at this several times and clueless to what this means. And would really like to know. 

I'm in the same boat.  I think it's the difference in the stat from 25 to 26, but a 49.5% difference in hard hit rate from one year to the next seems impossible.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I’d take this OF all day if it means they can sign Morejon.

LF - Duran

CF - PCA

RF - Shaw/Larnach platoon

I don’t think it would be Duran and Larnach. It would be “or”. And I really don’t think it will be Morejon no matter who they sign. I think they sign one left handed bat and one right handed bat. If they get two bats along with Bart and then young guys like Shaw, Alcantara, Ramirez and Triantos take the remaining spots they could have around $50M-$55M to add pitching and stay under the LT or $75M to stay around where they were last year. Obviously I like the second option best. They can get 3 solid starters and add a pen arm or a wildcard/swing starter. But even at $50-$55M they should be able to add 3 starters.

Posted
4 minutes ago, mul21 said:

I'm in the same boat.  I think it's the difference in the stat from 25 to 26, but a 49.5% difference in hard hit rate from one year to the next seems impossible.

The 74% GB and K rate doesn’t make sense to me either. Honestly none of it does. I honestly have no idea of what those numbers mean. 

Posted (edited)
23 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I don’t think it would be Duran and Larnach. It would be “or”. And I really don’t think it will be Morejon no matter who they sign. I think they sign one left handed bat and one right handed bat. If they get two bats along with Bart and then young guys like Shaw, Alcantara, Ramirez and Triantos take the remaining spots they could have around $50M-$55M to add pitching and stay under the LT or $75M to stay around where they were last year. Obviously I like the second option best. They can get 3 solid starters and add a pen arm or a wildcard/swing starter. But even at $50-$55M they should be able to add 3 starters.

well why not *and*?

Duran as an everyday guy. which he has proven he is based on availability, and Larnach/Shaw platoon in the other corner. If they landed Duran I can understand not going after Sato since that’s too many everyday LHH in OF, but my scenario is a platoon, and a potentially very solid outfield for the price.

Morejon aside, Even if the Cubs pick up Duran and a solid RHH for RF, could still use Larnach as a DH versus RHP and a backup OFer. I can see ways they could both fit (Michael Conforto role).

If Jed’s going to build this roster off of waivers and non tenders let’s go all out

Edited by Nolo
Posted

 

21 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

Bertz, please excuse my ignorance. But what do these numbers represent? I have looked at this several times and clueless to what this means. And would really like to know. 

 

19 minutes ago, mul21 said:

I'm in the same boat.  I think it's the difference in the stat from 25 to 26, but a 49.5% difference in hard hit rate from one year to the next seems impossible.

This isn't a technically smart answer, but I think generally the way to look at those numbers is that the higher the percentage is, the more likely the player is to replicate the output in the next season. Like, I believe a 100% result would imply a statistic that stayed perfectly consistent from year one to year two. 

Given Bertz' comment at the end and my general understanding of reliability of one statistic vs another, the takeaways to me are that HR/FB is completely luck driven, and xFIP is the best of the ERA/xERA/FIP/xFIP group for predicting future performance.

I could be wrong, but that's how I'm reading it. Also would love to see wOBA/xwOBA/FG projections compared on the offensive side. 

  • Like 1
Posted
17 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

Bertz, please excuse my ignorance. But what do these numbers represent? I have looked at this several times and clueless to what this means. And would really like to know. 

 

14 minutes ago, mul21 said:

I'm in the same boat.  I think it's the difference in the stat from 25 to 26, but a 49.5% difference in hard hit rate from one year to the next seems impossible.

So these are the correlations between these stats year over year.  ERA for instance has a 31% correlation between year 1 and year 2.  Correlation can go between 0%, meaning there's no relationship at all, and 100%, meaning there is a perfect 1 to 1 relationship.

So the tl;dr on this data is that strikeouts, groundball rate, and walks are pretty consistent year over year, statcast numbers like hard hit rate a step down from that, and things like BABIP, homerun per flyball, and left on base rate are very inconsistent year to year.  Among ERA estimators, xFIP is the most stable year over year by a good amount.

There's some room for nuance here, but broadly I would say the closer to 1 something is the more it's a sign of skill, the closer to 0 it is the more it's a sign of luck.

Posted
6 minutes ago, squally1313 said:

 

 

This isn't a technically smart answer, but I think generally the way to look at those numbers is that the higher the percentage is, the more likely the player is to replicate the output in the next season. Like, I believe a 100% result would imply a statistic that stayed perfectly consistent from year one to year two. 

Given Bertz' comment at the end and my general understanding of reliability of one statistic vs another, the takeaways to me are that HR/FB is completely luck driven, and xFIP is the best of the ERA/xERA/FIP/xFIP group for predicting future performance.

I could be wrong, but that's how I'm reading it. Also would love to see wOBA/xwOBA/FG projections compared on the offensive side. 

Yeah this is right on.  I should do offense next, and I like the idea of testing projections.  Especially now that FG has historical ones.  Like I think we're both on the same page that ZiPS > Steamer but to what degree?

Posted
4 minutes ago, Bertz said:

Yeah this is right on.  I should do offense next, and I like the idea of testing projections.  Especially now that FG has historical ones.  Like I think we're both on the same page that ZiPS > Steamer but to what degree?

Honestly, I thought the request was going to come off as a little snarky because of the real wide gap in Shaw's xwOBA v 2027 projections. Which obviously depends on how good the projections are at having a handle on age/experience related movements. I feel like conventional wisdom was a peak after a couple years pro followed by a long tail, but then I feel like the 2016-2020 Cubs had me thinking you basically start at the top and just decline at various speeds. But now there's someone like PCA, so who knows. 

Posted
32 minutes ago, Bertz said:

 

So these are the correlations between these stats year over year.  ERA for instance has a 31% correlation between year 1 and year 2.  Correlation can go between 0%, meaning there's no relationship at all, and 100%, meaning there is a perfect 1 to 1 relationship.

So the tl;dr on this data is that strikeouts, groundball rate, and walks are pretty consistent year over year, statcast numbers like hard hit rate a step down from that, and things like BABIP, homerun per flyball, and left on base rate are very inconsistent year to year.  Among ERA estimators, xFIP is the most stable year over year by a good amount.

There's some room for nuance here, but broadly I would say the closer to 1 something is the more it's a sign of skill, the closer to 0 it is the more it's a sign of luck.

Thank you. 

Posted
1 minute ago, squally1313 said:

Honestly, I thought the request was going to come off as a little snarky because of the real wide gap in Shaw's xwOBA v 2027 projections. Which obviously depends on how good the projections are at having a handle on age/experience related movements. I feel like conventional wisdom was a peak after a couple years pro followed by a long tail, but then I feel like the 2016-2020 Cubs had me thinking you basically start at the top and just decline at various speeds. But now there's someone like PCA, so who knows. 

I think the latest I've seen is that offense peaks around that 27-30 range that was historically considered a player's prime, defense peaks closer to 22/23, and so guys overall peak 25-27. There might be more up to date #s but I think that's ballpark.

And then on the xwOBA thing, I remember Szymborski saying the rule of thumb is a blend of 2/3s xwOBA 1/3rd regular wOBA is most predictive for the next year, sans any other context. So for Shaw that'd be a .310ish wOBA which is a ~97 wRC+.  That said the added context: Shaw's age, speed, and minor league production, would point you towards the over.

Posted
49 minutes ago, Nolo said:

well why not *and*?

Duran as an everyday guy. which he has proven he is based on availability, and Larnach/Shaw platoon in the other corner. If they landed Duran I can understand not going after Sato since that’s too many everyday LHH in OF, but my scenario is a platoon, and a potentially very solid outfield for the price.

Morejon aside, Even if the Cubs pick up Duran and a solid RHH for RF, could still use Larnach as a DH versus RHP and a backup OFer. I can see ways they could both fit (Michael Conforto role).

If Jed’s going to build this roster off of waivers and non tenders let’s go all out

You make a good point. But most things I see have the Cubs getting a right handed bat and a left handed bat. Considering how high you are on Duran I understand why you call him an everyday player. But Ramirez is also better from the left side. IDK, maybe they can do 2 lefties. I will say it is more likely than 2 right handed bats. But I think both are less likely than 1 of each.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Cubs legend Chris Morel was non-tendered.

Sign Morel and Duran and use all the remaining money on pitching. YUCK! 
BTW, in case anyone isn’t sure about this, I’m kidding. Morel is terrible. 

Edited by Rcal10

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...