Ichiro V. ARod

[hardcorecubfan]

Ok, assume we have the resources right now to sign either for the rest of the year. they both are clamouring for the Cubs (assuming)

 

which would you take right now and why. Remembering Jac Jones as a center fielder and Izturas as a shortstop.

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Arod...easily.

 

Play him at short, play him in RF. It doesn't matter. Arod's value dwarfs Ichiro and I don't even think it is close.

[B]

Arod...easily.

 

Play him at short, play him in RF. It doesn't matter. Arod's value dwarfs Ichiro and I don't even think it is close.

 

I was gonna say that, but didn't feel like typing it.

[Drew Doughty]

is there really a debate here?

 

ichiro is a great centerfielder. alex rodriguez is probably the best player in baseball right now.

 

no question, ARod.

[wekse]

haha, dumbest poll ever.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

haha, dumbest poll ever.

 

exactly

[E.J.]

Alright. I want to know the person who voted for Ichiro.

[Skyballer]

Alright. I want to know the person who voted for Ichiro.

I voted for Alex, who would vote for Ichiro he is a very very good CF and baseball player but A-Rod is far superior.

[B]

Alright. I want to know the person who voted for Ichiro.

 

I would guess the person that started the poll. Everyone else thinks the poll is ridiculous.

[Flames24Rulz]

Wow. Ichiro is a good outfielder, but how could you go with him over the best player in the game?

[soccer10k]

Uh, ARod.

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Wow...this is turning out to be a bigger landslide than Raisin's victory over Reds44 in the NSBB polls, and I never thought I'd see another one that lopsided again.

[NCCubFan]

Alright. I want to know the person who voted for Ichiro.

 

I would guess the person that started the poll.

Or else a Cards fan who can't stand the thought of the Cubs getting Arod. :D

[reds44]

Wow...this is turning out to be a bigger landslide than Raisin's victory over Reds44 in the NSBB polls, and I never thought I'd see another one that lopsided again.

Oh you slay me!

 

Lets give it up for Vance everyone.

[CubmanPi]

Yea, I really didn't expect Ichiro to have a vote.

[Roast]

No, honestly, I want to know the reason behind the vote for Ichiro.

 

Seriously...fess up. Why?

[Ding Dong Johnson]

No, honestly, I want to know the reason behind the vote for Ichiro.

 

Seriously...fess up. Why?

 

(can't stand the nickname AROD)

[abuck1220]

next poll -- who was better in their prime...lou gehrig or manny trillo?

[soccer10k]

Is this the most lopsided poll in the history of NSBB?

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Is this the most lopsided poll in the history of NSBB?

 

I think so.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

Is this the most lopsided poll in the history of NSBB?

 

if by lopsided you mean idiotic, yes

[Derwood]

next poll -- who was better in their prime...lou gehrig or mario mendoza?

 

fixed

[CubinNY]

This one should not be close.

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

This one should not be close.

 

It's not.

[TruffleShuffle]

Alright. I want to know the person who voted for Ichiro.

 

I would guess the person that started the poll. Everyone else thinks the poll is ridiculous.

 

it wouldn't be ridiculous if the cubs had a good SS and no CF, since Ichiro does have the fourth highest VORP in the game. But since the Cubs are inept at SS, it's an easy answer.