One guy who had one good year and then declined significantly. Not much of a case so far. So you believe '09 is Soto's true talent level. And that his '07 sucked. I think his true talent is probably somewhere between his 08 and 09, and his 60 PA in 07 don't really merit mentioning. Last I started paying close attention to the Cubs this year, Soto was absurdly unlucky on balls in play. He might not be as good as he was in '08, but he took a giant leap forward with 1 year of Joshua. I don't know why you'd toss out Soto's AAA #s that year. And why previously, you've stated you don't care what guys have done at AAA under him. Do you not believe that AAA stats translate to the majors?