Contract length and total value wise, perhaps. But I have to agree with the nominations of Todd "Flipping the Bird" Hundley and Mel Rojas are worse free agent signing. I would also nominate the group signing of Randy Myers, Jose Bautista, Dan Plesac, and Candy Maldonado for the money saved by not re-signing Maddux. None of those players stayed in Chicago for more then 3 yrs, and only Myers was remotely productive during their stay with the Cubs.