Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted
1 hour ago, gflore34 said:

And, I wouldn't pencil Steele into the rotation, I believe he's closer to cooked than a contributor in 2027.

I really think if the Cubs give him a contract, he will be in the rotation. If he is cooked they aren’t doing it. So if he is on the team he probably will start. 

  • Like 1
  • Replies 707
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Just now, Rcal10 said:

 

I agree he won’t cost $30 a year.  I also agree he isn’t coming back. I just don’t think they will allocate that amount to one corner outfielder. Even a low end estimate if something like 4/$88M doesn’t really leave enough dorn3 pitchers added along with 2 other bats(one being a catcher).  Whenever I suggest him or agree with wanting him, it is more wishful thinking than expecting him back. 

Yeah I doubt he gets to $30m, but I do think you're going to get (insert team here) to give him more money than we think he'll get. This market is horrendous for hitters and Suzuki is easily the top of the class. 

If we all think Skubal is the most unlikely free agent (and based on how the Cubs immediately pissed all over any report they liked him, I think he probably is right now) than I'm kind of of the mind that Seiya is the second least likely. Or maybe third behind Arozerena. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Jason Ross said:

Yeah I doubt he gets to $30m, but I do think you're going to get (insert team here) to give him more money than we think he'll get. This market is horrendous for hitters and Suzuki is easily the top of the class. 

If we all think Skubal is the most unlikely free agent (and based on how the Cubs immediately pissed all over any report they liked him, I think he probably is right now) than I'm kind of of the mind that Seiya is the second least likely. Or maybe third behind Arozerena. 

Third seems about right. If they did allocate enough money to sign Arozarena or Suzuki, I think they would sign Seiya. So Skubal most likely not to sign, Arozarena second, Suzuki third. Bottome line is he isn’t coming. That being the case I really hope he ends up with 5/$125M. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

I'm rooting for you, Michael, You could use a win.

As someone mentioned elsewhere, it could mean that the Sato market isn't there right now. His profile is really not in the Cubs' wheelhouse but I can seem them trying to jump in on a weak market and go with a strong AAV and shorter terms.

Posted
1 minute ago, Jason Ross said:

As someone mentioned elsewhere, it could mean that the Sato market isn't there right now. His profile is really not in the Cubs' wheelhouse but I can seem them trying to jump in on a weak market and go with a strong AAV and shorter terms.

Do you think he ends up with a Murakami-type contract? I'd go for it if that's the case.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Do you think he ends up with a Murakami-type contract? I'd go for it if that's the case.

He has two major things working against him: he's not really a 3b and he's really prone to striking out. Strike out hitters just don't last super long and as an OF'er he's going up against a few other good hitters. If teams are super wary? Yeah a Murakami deal is realistic. 

If teams think he's more Okamoto than Murakami? He's in the 4-5 year territory. 

You can convince me of the Murakami territory. I'm incredibly concerned with the bat-to-ball concerns to go above that though.

Posted

At the risk of lacking nuance, the Cubs returning offensive players combined for more fWAR in 2026 than every other team in baseball and we keep hearing there's like $75m to spend, so it's a little disappointing to be like 'ok so you know how the best pitcher is the least likely free agent acquisition for us? well, get this, the best hitter is the second least likely acquisition'. I get that you can look at a depth chart and see a bunch of blanks, but it's worth remembering that a bunch of those blanks were filled by not very good pitchers, so I don't really buy into the fact that we need to spread the money out on a bunch of #4 starters. If you're not going to increase your #1 starter production by 4 wins, why not go sign the corner outfielder that contributed to the giant gap we had offensively over every other team in baseball. 

Sorry, this is ranty, but read that PCA thread earlier and was similarly struck by how little everyone seemed to care and it's just because the general vibe of all this is so low ceiling-ed. Sign two awesome players and back fill the rest. They won't be worse than the rotation from last year. 

Posted
1 minute ago, squally1313 said:

At the risk of lacking nuance, the Cubs returning offensive players combined for more fWAR in 2026 than every other team in baseball and we keep hearing there's like $75m to spend, so it's a little disappointing to be like 'ok so you know how the best pitcher is the least likely free agent acquisition for us? well, get this, the best hitter is the second least likely acquisition'. I get that you can look at a depth chart and see a bunch of blanks, but it's worth remembering that a bunch of those blanks were filled by not very good pitchers, so I don't really buy into the fact that we need to spread the money out on a bunch of #4 starters. If you're not going to increase your #1 starter production by 4 wins, why not go sign the corner outfielder that contributed to the giant gap we had offensively over every other team in baseball. 

Sorry, this is ranty, but read that PCA thread earlier and was similarly struck by how little everyone seemed to care and it's just because the general vibe of all this is so low ceiling-ed. Sign two awesome players and back fill the rest. They won't be worse than the rotation from last year. 

Probably not, but who are those guys that are going to pitch the necessary innings?  Like, they don't even have enough competent arms right now to fill a rotation even if they sign Skubal.  We ran into a problem last year where there were so many injuries they literally didn't have enough starters until they went the emergency trade route for Peterson.  They're going to need 10 guys they think can start games at some point during the year to fill ~900 innings and the only reliable arm they have in house right now is Assad.

Posted
18 minutes ago, mul21 said:

Probably not, but who are those guys that are going to pitch the necessary innings?  Like, they don't even have enough competent arms right now to fill a rotation even if they sign Skubal.  We ran into a problem last year where there were so many injuries they literally didn't have enough starters until they went the emergency trade route for Peterson.  They're going to need 10 guys they think can start games at some point during the year to fill ~900 innings and the only reliable arm they have in house right now is Assad.

Fair point, but if you're going to include Assad as a reliable arm, you probably have to throw Cabrera and Garrett in the mix as being similarly mediocre but currently healthy. I just don't know why it has to be 4 $15m starters and not 40/10/5/5. 

Conceding your general point though, and using it to, staying negative for the time being, acknowledge just how incredibly and comprehensively horsefeathered the entire pitching situation is. Just so totally indictingly bleak

  • Like 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, squally1313 said:

Just so totally indictingly bleak

Yep. Our rotation as it stands right now would be Steele, Assad, Garrett, Cabrera, and Wicks. That's it. Only depth options would be guys that haven't made their major league debut (Wiggins, Sanders, and Birdsell)

Posted

It think the biggest issue is there are other teams that want/need 3 starting pitchers too. Plus several other teams also looking for one or two guys.!Cubs are going to be competing with these teams. So the idea of getting 3 guys they really want is hard to see really happening. We might have to realize there is probably 12-15 guys the Cubs could possibly sign and the 3 they get might not be the top 3 on their board. 

  • Like 1
Posted
42 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Yep. Our rotation as it stands right now would be Steele, Assad, Garrett, Cabrera, and Wicks. That's it. Only depth options would be guys that haven't made their major league debut (Wiggins, Sanders, and Birdsell)

This right here is where Hoyer failed this team. 

How do you finish a season and go into an offseason with basically question marks of a rotation and zero prospects that are close to being ready for a call up ?

Then there's speculation that they may be on a budget this offseason, which could leave them with at most 70+ mil to spend on multiple positions ( SP, OF, C) needed, so because of that the likelihood of adding tier 1 or maybe even tier 2 type players since they need multiple players are slim to none.

We're going to see just how creative Hoyer can be with payroll if he is limited and obviously looks to compete in 2027.

  • Like 1
Posted
21 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

How do you finish a season and go into an offseason with basically question marks of a rotation and zero prospects that are close to being ready for a call up ?

Hey but at least he got his own contract extended!

Posted
1 hour ago, chibears55 said:

This right here is where Hoyer failed this team. 

How do you finish a season and go into an offseason with basically question marks of a rotation and zero prospects that are close to being ready for a call up ?

Then there's speculation that they may be on a budget this offseason, which could leave them with at most 70+ mil to spend on multiple positions ( SP, OF, C) needed, so because of that the likelihood of adding tier 1 or maybe even tier 2 type players since they need multiple players are slim to none.

We're going to see just how creative Hoyer can be with payroll if he is limited and obviously looks to compete in 2027.

To be fair, we don’t know his payroll. You are speculating $70M. Most think more. But even at $70M he could bring in 2 solid starters and maybe a guy like Peterson. Or if they spend more on the first two maybe a guy like Civali or Sandoval. That type guy. Still have money to maybe get a couple bats that mayb total $20M.  Also, tbf, hard to go into last season and assume injuries they had as well as poor performance by Cabrera. At the start of last year Jed was looking at Horton, Cabrera and Steele for 2027. Possibly Wiggins coming up and Brown as a potential young arm coming. Now, things went south. I agree. But how do we blame Hoyer for all that happened? I don’t know what you consider tier 1 or tier 2, but even putting $50M towards pitching this off season they could come away with something like Tiara, Holmes and Peterson. There are other options too. May. Mahle, Flaherty, Gray, Rogers, Soroka, Bubic, etc…That isn’t bad. And, that using your figure at $70M. Taira $17M a year, Holmes $18M a year and Peterson $13M. Gives them enough to add offense. Suggesting Hoyer has failed the team before anything is done this off season is kind of putting the carriage before the horse. Let’s see how it plays out. IMO he has a lot of options. And I also think he has more money to spend than you think he has. Guess we shall see🤷

Posted
52 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Replace Imanaga and Suzuki with Taira and Sato 😅

Not sure about Sato, but I would be fine with Taira. 

Posted (edited)
13 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

To be fair, we don’t know his payroll. You are speculating $70M. Most think more. But even at $70M he could bring in 2 solid starters and maybe a guy like Peterson. Or if they spend more on the first two maybe a guy like Civali or Sandoval. That type guy. Still have money to maybe get a couple bats that mayb total $20M.  Also, tbf, hard to go into last season and assume injuries they had as well as poor performance by Cabrera. At the start of last year Jed was looking at Horton, Cabrera and Steele for 2027. Possibly Wiggins coming up and Brown as a potential young arm coming. Now, things went south. I agree. But how do we blame Hoyer for all that happened? I don’t know what you consider tier 1 or tier 2, but even putting $50M towards pitching this off season they could come away with something like Tiara, Holmes and Peterson. There are other options too. May. Mahle, Flaherty, Gray, Rogers, Soroka, Bubic, etc…That isn’t bad. And, that using your figure at $70M. Taira $17M a year, Holmes $18M a year and Peterson $13M. Gives them enough to add offense. Suggesting Hoyer has failed the team before anything is done this off season is kind of putting the carriage before the horse. Let’s see how it plays out. IMO he has a lot of options. And I also think he has more money to spend than you think he has. Guess we shall see🤷

I did say speculation and at least 70+..lol

Edited by chibears55
Posted
9 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I did say speculation and at least 70+..lol

I know. I said you speculated $70M+. And you might be right. I just responded to your post showing even at your number they can be good. I would rather the off season play out before criticizing Hoyer as failing the team. 

Posted

Max to stay under the CBT of 247 would be around 76. Probably 78 if we assume Arias and Roberts get non-tendered. Would love to go over but my hopes for that ended when they immediately let everyone know they weren’t pursuing Skubal

Posted
21 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

Max to stay under the CBT of 247 would be around 76. Probably 78 if we assume Arias and Roberts get non-tendered. Would love to go over but my hopes for that ended when they immediately let everyone know they weren’t pursuing Skubal

Not going after Skubal and not going over the first LT line are entirely different things. TBH, Skubal for 8 years and $350M would concern me too. Don’t get me wrong, if they signed him I would be very excited. But choosing not to give him a long term contract at over $40M a year is not a sign they won’t spend. It just says they don’t want to sign any pitcher for that annual and those years. They may stay under. As Chibear said, they might only spend $70M. I just don’t take the Skubal news as a sign they won’t spend. 

Posted

I’ve come to terms with no Skubal, but they need to get someone who resembles an ace, or at least a SOLID #2. Would be pretty bummed if they end up getting a few 3’s and 4’s… or worse.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Nolo said:

I’ve come to terms with no Skubal, but they need to get someone who resembles an ace, or at least a SOLID #2. Would be pretty bummed if they end up getting a few 3’s and 4’s… or worse.

Who though? Guys have made a good argument that King and Peralta shouldn’t be offered a contract. So that leave Rogers, Gray, Gausman, Holmes? Am I missing someone? Would those guys qualify as solid #2’s? There is only 1 ace available. I would be happy with 3 guys if 2 came from Taira, Holmes, Gray, Rogers, Gausman and a 3rd came from Mahle, Peterson, May. Soroka, , etc…. Obviously there are some combos I like better than others, but depending on what they can spend, some combos might not be available. 

Posted
37 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I know. I said you speculated $70M+. And you might be right. I just responded to your post showing even at your number they can be good. I would rather the off season play out before criticizing Hoyer as failing the team. 

Only real criticism i have of Hoyer is his constant go to of signing low cost veterans, guys coming off injuries, and released players hoping to strike gold but its usually just payroll eaters that mostly get waived eventually. 

As far as whatever payroll is,  if criticism is due, it should be pointed at Ricketts, Hoyer and his staff just need to do a little better job at evaluating who to spend it on to make sure they have a full competitive roster

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...