Question of the week: do you care more about a floor or a cap?

[Brock Beauchamp]

This is the first DiamondCentric-wide poll, click into the link to vote. Do you care more about the next CBA having a salary cap or a salary floor? I know many of you want to hammer "both!", but ya gotta choose one.

Do you care more about MLB mandating a salary floor or a salary cap? - DiamondCentric

DIAMONDCENTRIC.NET

[Jason Ross]

Neither. I care about a system that ensures players have a fair slice of the profits. A cap or a floor without open books will almost entirely favor management. The best system would be one in which the cap and floor is defined yearly based on open, transparent profits. Sadly, with MLB's anti-trust exemptions, that's impossible now. And I don't blindly believe a cap or a floor will create any more or less parity than we currently have.

[jersey cubs fan]

You can’t have one without the other and they shouldn’t have either. 
 

bad question that eliminates valid opinions from the discussion