2018 HR Derby {Discussion & Transaction Thread}

Southpaw19 · May 15, 2018

Drop Miguel Cabrera and add Matt Chapman.

Done and done. This is your first transaction of the first half.

You have one remaining.

Southpaw19 · May 15, 2018

Was Albies not eligible as a WC?

He's Listed Here

So then, wouldn't he be the best possible WC pick?

I know it may not make the most sense, but when I listed out "best possible team", the wild card, is if you had chosen all the players in groups A-D, AND had the best Wild Card of those players selected.

Southpaw19 · May 15, 2018

Wow... Robinson Cano is suspended for 80 games, and no one has him on their team. No need to panic! Everything is fine! :yahoo:

SouthSideRyan · May 15, 2018

He's Listed Here

So then, wouldn't he be the best possible WC pick?

I know it may not make the most sense, but when I listed out "best possible team", the wild card, is if you had chosen all the players in groups A-D, AND had the best Wild Card of those players selected.

So it'll be switched when everyone changes to Albies at the break.

Andy · May 16, 2018

Fantastic, I'll go ahead and burn my 2nd transaction on one lineup spot because of the Pollock injury

Drop Pollock, add Matt Chapman

Sammy Sofa · May 16, 2018

Drop Bradley, add Betts.

Cespedes will probably turn out to have a wicked case of bonitis in his hip, but man, Bradley SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS so far this season.

PackLandVA · May 16, 2018

Fantastic, I'll go ahead and burn my 2nd transaction on one lineup spot because of the Pollock injury

Drop Pollock, add Matt Chapman

Super glad I used Trade #1 last week to GET Pollock. I’ve got this whole HR Derby thing figured out.

Aaron_Kennelly · May 16, 2018

Kept Cabrera on my roster even though he's butt and has been injured for two weeks. Planned it perfectly by being lazy and waiting until Pollock coincidentally got hurt to make a move.

Cubswin11 · May 16, 2018

Drop Pollock

Add Lorenzo Cain (don’t be afraid to have a similar fate as Pollock)

sweetpeteman · May 16, 2018

Drop Pollock, add Belt

Southpaw19 · May 16, 2018

Fantastic, I'll go ahead and burn my 2nd transaction on one lineup spot because of the Pollock injury

Drop Pollock, add Matt Chapman

Done and done. This is your second transaction of the first half.

You have zero remaining.

Southpaw19 · May 16, 2018

Drop Bradley, add Betts.

Cespedes will probably turn out to have a wicked case of bonitis in his hip, but man, Bradley SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS so far this season.

Different player groups. Try again.

Southpaw19 · May 16, 2018

Drop Pollock
Add Lorenzo Cain (don’t be afraid to have a similar fate as Pollock)

Done and done. This is your second transaction of the first half.

You have zero remaining.

Southpaw19 · May 16, 2018

Drop Pollock, add Belt

Done and done. This is your second transaction of the first half.

You have zero remaining.

Sammy Sofa · May 16, 2018

Drop Bradley, add Betts.

Cespedes will probably turn out to have a wicked case of bonitis in his hip, but man, Bradley SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS so far this season.

Different player groups. Try again.

horsefeathers. Make it Haniger, please.

Southpaw19 · May 17, 2018

Drop Bradley, add Betts.

Cespedes will probably turn out to have a wicked case of bonitis in his hip, but man, Bradley SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS so far this season.

Different player groups. Try again.

horsefeathers. Make it Haniger, please.

Done and done. This is your first transaction of the first half.

You have one remaining.

Southpaw19 · May 21, 2018

2018 HR DERBY SCOREBOARD (as of May 20, 2018)

=========================================

1. TomtheBombadil (100) +12

2. Duke Silver (99) +10

3. Agony & Ivy (97) +12

treebird (97) +11

5. SouthSideRyan (96) +12

The Logan (96) +7

7. Sammy Sofa (94) +12

8. NonProfitCow (91) +7

9. Derwood (90) +9

10. Cubswin11 (89) +8

Southpaw19 (89) +12

sweetpeteman (89) +12

13. Liam Neeson (88) +14

philosophizer75 (88) +5

soccer10k (88) +9

16. Andy (85) +9

17. Brian707 (84) +8

18. abmillis (83) +9

evv98 (83) +9

20. SeldomSeen (81) +9

21. javy knows my name (80) +8

22. Tinkertini26 (79) +13

23. Ding Dong Johnson (77) +2

PackLandVA (77) +12

25. abohnhoff (76) +6

26. Bobson Dugnutt (72) +8

27. woodchip2153 (65) +5

Biggest Jump of the Week: Liam Neeson

BEST POSSIBLE TEAM SCORE (146)

GROUP A - J.D. Martinez (15)

GROUP B - Manny Machado (14), Mike Trout (14)

GROUP C - Mookie Betts (15), Bryce Harper (13), Jose Ramirez (13)

GROUP D - A.J. Pollock (11), Brandon Belt (11), C.J. Cron (11), Mitch Haniger (11), Yangervis Solarte (10)

WILD CARD - Gregory Polanco OR Rafael Devers (8)

Aaron_Kennelly · May 21, 2018

Southpaw19 · May 28, 2018

2018 HR DERBY SCOREBOARD (as of May 27, 2018)

=========================================

1. Agony & Ivy (108) +11

SouthSideRyan (108) +12

treebird (108) +11

4. Duke Silver (106) +7

TomtheBombadil (106) +6

6. The Logan (103) +7

7. Sammy Sofa (102) +8

8. soccer10k (100) +12

9. Cubswin11 (99) +10

Southpaw19 (99) +10

11. Derwood (98) +8

12. NonProfitCow (97) +6

sweetpeteman (97) +8

14. philosophizer75 (95) +7

15. Liam Neeson (94) +6

16. evv98 (93) +10

17. abmillis (92) +9

Andy (92) +7

19. Brian707 (90) +6

Ding Dong Johnson (90) +13

SeldomSeen (90) +9

22. PackLandVA (89) +12

23. javy knows my name (87) +7

24. abohnhoff (84) +8

25. Tinkertini26 (83) +4

26. Bobson Dugnutt (79) +7

27. woodchip2153 (76) +11

Biggest Jump of the Week: Ding Dong Johnson

BEST POSSIBLE TEAM SCORE (160)

GROUP A - J.D. Martinez (16)

GROUP B - Mike Trout (17), Manny Machado (15)

GROUP C - Mookie Betts (17), Bryce Harper (16), Jose Ramirez (15)

GROUP D - A.J. Pollock (11), Brandon Belt (11), C.J. Cron (11), Mitch Haniger (11), Yangervis Solarte (11)

WILD CARD - Rafael Devers (9)

Southpaw19 · May 29, 2018

Does switching from Barretto to Polanco during preseason as my WC count as a transaction?

No.

Southpaw19 · June 4, 2018

2018 HR DERBY SCOREBOARD (as of June 3, 2018)

=========================================

1. Agony & Ivy (122) +14

2. SouthSideRyan (121) +13

treebird (121) +13

4. Duke Silver (118) +12

5. The Logan (116) +13

6. TomtheBombadil (114) +8

7. Cubswin11 (113) +14

Sammy Sofa (113) +11

soccer10k (113) +13

10. NonProfitCow (109) +12

11. Derwood (108) +10

12. sweetpeteman (107) +10

13. Andy (106) +14

Liam Neeson (106) +12

15. philosophizer75 (105) +10

Southpaw19 (105) +6

17. abmillis (104) +12

evv98 (104) +11

19. Ding Dong Johnson (103) +13

20. PackLandVA (102) +13

21. SeldomSeen (101) +11

22. javy knows my name (97) +10

23. abohnhoff (94) +10

Brian707 (94) +4

Tinkertini26 (94) +11

26. Bobson Dugnutt (90) +11

27. woodchip2153 (88) +12

Biggest Jump of the Week: Agony & Ivy and Cubswin11

BEST POSSIBLE TEAM SCORE (177)

GROUP A - J.D. Martinez (19)

GROUP B - Mike Trout (19), Manny Machado (18)

GROUP C - Bryce Harper (18), Jose Ramirez (18), Mookie Betts (17)

GROUP D - C.J. Cron (12), Mitch Haniger (12), Yangervis Solarte (12), AND TWO OF THE FOLLOWING THREE: A.J. Pollock (11), Brandon Belt (11), Tim Anderson (11)

WILD CARD - Ian Desmond (10)

Sammy Sofa · June 6, 2018

Drop Hoskins

Add Cron (BY CROM!!!!!)

Agony and Ivy · June 6, 2018

Drop Hoskins

Add Haniger

soccer10k · June 7, 2018

Drop Hoskins

Add Belt

Southpaw19 · June 7, 2018

Drop Hoskins
Add Cron (BY CROM!!!!!)

Done and done. This is your second transaction of the first half.

You have zero remaining.

2018 HR Derby {Discussion & Transaction Thread}

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Create an account or sign in to comment

Create an account

Sign in

Member Statistics

Prospect News & Highlights

Recent News

Notes & Rumors

Recent Blogs