FINAL SCORE (3) Queen-53 (1) Pink Floyd-48 (OT)

[Derwood]

(1) Pink Floyd

 

- ROUND 1 - Defeated (16) Motley Crue 57-21

- ROUND 2 - Defeated (8 ) Pearl Jam 51-25

- SWEET 16 - Defeated (4) Guns N' Roses 46-34

 

 

(3) Queen

 

- ROUND 1 - Defeated (14) Rage Against the Machine 49-19

- ROUND 2 - Defeated (11) Lynyrd Skynyrd 58-33

- SWEET 16 - Defeated (2) Black Sabbath 40-20

Edited August 7, 2006 by Derwood

[Tracer Bullet]

Didn't really even have to think about this one.

[Soul]

Whoops, you've got the Beatles roundup instead of Floyd, Der.

 

 

 

Voted Queen. Difficult though, I love Pink Floyd too.

[Derwood]

Whoops, you've got the Beatles roundup instead of Floyd, Der.

.

 

fixed

[MPrior]

This is where it starts getting really hard. I love both of these bands. But with Queen, I feel as though I mostly only appreciate their bigger hits - album to album I'm not crazy about them. Pink Floyd, on the other hand, has created several incredible albums as well as numerous incredible songs (more, I think, than Queen). So I gotta go Pink Floyd.

[cubweiser03]

I prefer Pink to Queen. I really never get to excited about Queen. I dont think they suck im just luke warm on them. My wife said Floyd was the best concert she has ever gone too, so also for her im casting this vote.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I'll take Queen.

[Soul]

I have a feeling this whole thing is coming down to Zep vs. Beatles.

 

 

That will be a hell of a battle if it happens.

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

I'm voting Queen here.

[Mizzou]

Queen has the lead over Pink Floyd? Queen?!

[ResidentRoyalsFan]

Floyd. All the other great bands are out, so I really hope they, or maybe the stones go all the way.

[soccer10k]

Pink Floyd had better win this matchup.

[goonys evil twin]

Queen has the lead over Pink Floyd? Queen?!

 

Seriously, Queen? That's just silly.

[Soul]

Queen has the lead over Pink Floyd? Queen?!

 

Seriously, Queen? That's just silly.

 

Floyd eeks out in front.

 

Still though, why should it be silly for Queen to give Floyd a run? Queen was incredible, as was Floyd.

[wolf stansson]

haha now it's 19-18 queen.

[goonys evil twin]

 

Still though, why should it be silly for Queen to give Floyd a run? Queen was incredible, as was Floyd.

 

The only thing incredible about Queen was their incredible lack of incredibleness.

[ConstableRabbit]

Either should get trounced by their inevitable matchup with either LedZep or The Beatles.

 

I voted pf. I also am kind of lukewarm about Queen. They've got some great songs, but nothing I've peed my pants over*.

 

 

 

 

*note, I have never peed my pants for Pink Floys either, I was only closer to doing so than when listening to Queen

[Butterscup1679666578]

I voted for Pink Floyd, to tie it up.

[treebird]

I VOTE QUEEN TO TAKE DA LEAD

[Derwood]

everyone knows who i voted for

[MPrior]

C'mon now. There have to be more Pink Floyd fans out there. I love Queen, but they are pretty much a second-tier band (not that there's any shame in this; second-tier is pretty damn good). Pink Floyd, on the other hand, is really one of the greats.

[Derwood]

I knew this would be close, but I didn't think Queen would be winning. I really like both bands, but Queen has more songs in their catalog that I simply don't like. I own nearly 30 Pink Floyd CD's and there is very, very little I don't at least like. Queen is either "I love it" or "I hate it" with me.

[wolf stansson]

You guys are underestimating how many people HATE Pink Floyd.

[fiver]

just voted for floyd and quite upset that they are getting beat by queen

[T2E]

Hmm... Dark Side of the Moon vs. We Will Rock You

Wish You Were Here vs. Fat Bottom Girls

One of the most original groups ever vs. well...Queen.

 

I'll take Pink Floyd.