Baseball is not a game of specialists. You can't substitute in for offense/defense or when you need a power or an on-base oriented hitter very often. So every player has to be evaluated on at least 4 things: their ability to get on base, their ability to hit for power, their baserunning, and their defense. All of those come together to form the total package of a player. They aren't all weighted the same, but that's another argument entirely. If you have a player that contributes more overall over those 4 categories, then he should be the one starting. That's why looking at one category can cause invalid results. Yes, the Cubs don't need 8 power hitters. But that doesn't mean Theriot's major deficiency in power isn't a big problem that needs to be looked at when comparing him to other shortstops. The Cubs don't need everybody to be perfect on the basepaths. Theriot has had a deficiency on the basepaths this year though, and that shouldn't be ignored. Theriot's mediocre defense should not be ignored either. Now I happen to agree with you that when adding up all 4 categories, Theriot still comes out ahead of Cedeno. But choosing Theriot because of 1 skill is dangerous, because it doesn't help you figure out where you need to upgrade. Wouldn't it be nice if we could find a Theriot with a little more power and better defense? For enough of the first two, I'd sacrifice some of the OBP. So I agree with your conclusion that Theriot should be the starting SS until a better option comes along, and that right now there is no better option. But we should care about his power..because then we know what to look for to find players who are better than Theriot. I happen to think we're going to have a hard time finding one freely available when looking at how bad SS's have been in the majors this year. But only if we're honest about both a player's assets and limitations can we truly evaluate if we can upgrade and continue to make this team better. Good post, and I essentially agree. I didn't mean to imply that his lack of power is nothing to look at. Clearly it factors into the decision of who to start. Or who to trade/acquire in the offseason. My post was more out of frustration that we have this guy who's doing exactly what a person in his role (#2 hitter) should do -- get on base, move runners over, etc. Yet people are bitching that he doesn't hit for power. The guys behind him are supposed to hit for power. Theriot is doing his job. If we had a Chase Utley sitting on the bench, I'd be vocal that he should start. But we don't. We have Ronny Cedeno, who has never proven himself to be better than what Theriot has done this year. For the record, I'm not opposed to upgrading SS in the offseason. I'm not opposed to upgrading any position in the offseason. I don't think it's necessarily feasible for us to do so, but we'll see. I don't have this huge boner for Theriot. I just think that he's the best option on this team.