Soriano belongs at the top and not the middle... why? Career situational stats in lead-off, 3rd, and 4th position, the 3 spots where he's hit the most in his career: Lead-Off (2052AB) .291/.340/.544/.884 3rd (602AB) .264/.313/.460/.773 5th (575AB) .271/.316/.520/.836 Now you can say that his stats are stacked in the lead-off spot because he's had more opportunity for success, but he's also had more opportunity for failure, too. He primarily bat 3rd and 5th when he was in Texas, and he went from great in the lead-off for the Yankees to nothing spectacular for the Rangers in the 3/5 holes. And that was while he was hitting in the middle of a lineup that had Young, Teixiera, and Blalock. As soon as he went back to hitting lead-off after he was traded to the Nationals, he flourished, which coincidentally happened to be in the middle of his prime, which may or may not be a reason for the sudden boost in stats, especially wqhile hitting at RFK, predominantly a pitchers park, and also in a Nationals lineup that had no Mark Teixieras or Michael Youngs. If he bats lead-off in front of, what will appear to be, DeRosa, Lee, Ramirez, Jones, while he's hitting in Wrigley, I think he's going to actually end up producing like a $18MM man. Besides, the 5-6-7 sports should be reserved for Barrett-Murton-Jones. Barrett career 5-spot #'s (213AB): .305/.370/.540/.910 - Barrett actually has the best career numbers out of the 3 spot but that's Lee's position, unless you want to have a Barrett-Lee-Ramirez 3-4-5, which isn't likely) Murton career 6-spot #'s (136AB): .375/.437/.551/.989 Jones career 7-spot #'s (422AB): .301/.353/.479/.832 The lineup with who I think will be starting and how I think it should be if thats the case Soriano DeRosa Lee Ramirez Barrett Murton Jones Izturis That's how I feel about it anyways. Soriano at lead-off, I'm a strong advocate for it