he did keep on barking from the dugout. funny, my tape shows differently than yours. You have a little problem stitch, in Sun nite's post you claim NOW you claim you have the tape and the Edmonds was barking from the dugout. Now lets get back to my logic question, if Edmonds was the one who STARTED the barking, then wouldn't he continue barking all the way around the bases? and wouldn't he be barking back at Z as he rounded the bases? So wouldn't the tape that you say shows Edmonds barking from the dugout also show him barking around the basepaths, yet you don't claim that. So which is more likely, a camera focusing on Edmonds trotting around the basepaths when he supposedly started the barking OR a camera focusing on Edmonds in the dugout afterwards as the game on the field is continuing and a live AB is going on? Every time you log in to this site, do you immediately run a search for Edmonds?