Someone posted an interesting comparison on another board: QB A: 65.4% comp, 28591 yards, 182 TD/114 INT, 8.0 Y/A, 93.8 QB rating QB B: 63.0% comp, 26446 yards, 197 TD/86 INT, 7.2 Y/A, 92.9 QB rating Both players have made it to multiple Super Bowls. Are both, just one, or neither Hall-worthy and why? NFL HOF is more about reputation than stats. Very few people know how to calculate QB rating which means that writers probably don't care about it very much. I was going to guess that QB A is Brett Favre and QB B is Kurt Warner.