Jump to content
North Side Baseball
Posted
1 hour ago, Nolo said:

Who is the backup 1B if Busch gets injured or needs a day off? Ramirez and Shaw?

I think when Cubs figure out their backup/primary catcher, it should be someone who can also play some 1B. Busch probably got worn down in 2026 and he sure looked it by the end of the season (lifeless).

I know Ayers/Hartshorn play 1B but I'm talking big league guys, for now at least.

Alcantara 🤷 lol

  • Replies 530
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
1 hour ago, Nolo said:

Really not sure if they can afford to do that considering they would be losing an entire pitching rotation with zero certainty of how much time or how many players will be left after the lockout.

I think it's more probable they sign two starting pitchers before the lock, maybe one solid position player, and then wait out bullpen and catcher until after. Also, I'm thinking if any trades do happen, they will happen after.

You hope that the case, but with 2 weeks to go before December 1st, been pretty quiet on their part outside of Taira.

Maybe theres something going on with Petersen and possibly Holmes to return and one or both sign early,  but i think if Ricketts/Hoyer goal this coming season is to keep payroll low and then go into next offseason with knowledge of what the new agreement brings and more flexibility with future payroll, Hoyer is likely to sit and wait it out and then sign guys willing to accept 1 year pillow deals.

Guys like..

Gallen, Buehler, May, Bieber, Montgomery, Singer, maybe even Peterson would be candidates to do so

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
53 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I think that if Ricketts/Hoyer goal this coming season to keep payroll low and then go into next off season with knowledge of what the new agreement brings and more flexibility with future payroll Hoyer is likely to sit and wait it out and then sign guys willing to accept 1 year pillow 

 

Why is Hoyer “likely” to do this? Or, at least any more likely than any other GM. For years you create a narrative about Hoyer to suggest what he will do. Why are you assuming they plan on keeping the budget low? 

North Side Contributor
Posted
10 hours ago, chibears55 said:

Outside of the Japanese/Korean players, if the cubs are a possibility for one of them that need to sign by December 1st, it wouldn't surprise me if they waited until the lockout was over before acquiring anyone.

This would be a Hoyer thing to do, so if the lockout goes long, he may find guys willing to take 1 yr pillow deals just to get through the season and then have a normal offseason to test FA again. 

Literally the last time this happened the Cubs signed Marcus Stroman right before the CBA end date, so I'm not sure this is "a Hoyer thing to do". Past experience tells us sitting out the first part of the lockout is the opposite of a "Hoyer thing to do".

The Cubs likely need to add three-to-four SP, a few OF/DH types, a veteran catcher and seem likely to add some type of reliever if not multiple of the scrap-heap-types. They can't bring in 10 new players in three weeks in March. They're going to have to do something now.

  • Like 2
Posted
3 hours ago, Nolo said:

Who is the backup 1B if Busch gets injured or needs a day off? Ramirez and Shaw?

I think when Cubs figure out their backup/primary catcher, it should be someone who can also play some 1B. Busch probably got worn down in 2026 and he sure looked it by the end of the season (lifeless).

I know Ayers/Hartshorn play 1B but I'm talking big league guys, for now at least.

I know that there's no money for non-pitchers, but I would love to see them sign Goldschmidt. Platoon 1B/ DH who still mashes LHP.  He might cost $5 million.

North Side Contributor
Posted
11 minutes ago, Backtobanks said:

I know that there's no money for non-pitchers, but I would love to see them sign Goldschmidt. Platoon 1B/ DH who still mashes LHP.  He might cost $5 million.

There's certainly going to have to be money for non-pitchers. That said I'm way out on Goldy. His xwOBA dipped heavy last year but his wOBA was well above it. Bat speed tanked hard. He's 39 and hitters simply do not last. 

You're probably buying more "Justin Turner" than anything. And these parts loved themselves some J-Turn.

chart (3).png

 

Posted
21 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

Why is Hoyer “likely” to do this? Or, at least any more likely than any other GM. For years you create a narrative about Hoyer to suggest what he will do. Why are you assuming they plan on keeping the budget low? 

When i say keeping it low,  I mean under a Threshold if there is one.

Projected Threshold for 2027 if there is one it approximately 247 Mil, cubs payroll now is about 78 under that, so my guess is that if the plan is to stay under that. which has been mentioned as a possibility by baseball people that cover, then he'll spend upwards to 70 mil at least. 

In 6 years under Hoyer, hes gone over the Threshold twice, in 2024 and 2026, so, odds are pretty good that they stay under it again if there is one for 2027.

Why do I feel Hoyer is likely to wait ?

Because he has a history of waiting out the early asking prices of FA until they lower their ask. So, it would be unlike him to pounce on a FA early in the next 2 weeks that are looking for high dollars now before the deadline over waiting and getting guys that would consider accepting lower offers after its settled like I mentioned above. 

Now if he can nab a player or two willing to accept a low year low cost deal, then yea im sure he'll ink a deal, but I just dont see him inking a deal with anyone looking for years and money in next 2 weeks.

For the last couple years of my suggestions,  I bet I've been right or closer to being right then most who suggests all these players signed, high payroll, and trade scenarios 🤣

 

 

 

Posted
48 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

Literally the last time this happened the Cubs signed Marcus Stroman right before the CBA end date, so I'm not sure this is "a Hoyer thing to do". Past experience tells us sitting out the first part of the lockout is the opposite of a "Hoyer thing to do".

The Cubs likely need to add three-to-four SP, a few OF/DH types, a veteran catcher and seem likely to add some type of reliever if not multiple of the scrap-heap-types. They can't bring in 10 new players in three weeks in March. They're going to have to do something now.

That because Stroman accepted the 3 yr deal with an opt out after the 2nd year, the other top Starting pitchers were looking for 5 year deals.

Im not saying Hoyer wont sign anyone, just saying I dont expect him to sign anyone that looking for more than 2-3 years like Stroman did.

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
11 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

When i say keeping it low,  I mean under a Threshold if there is one.

Projected Threshold for 2027 if there is one it approximately 247 Mil, cubs payroll now is about 78 under that, so my guess is that if the plan is to stay under that. which has been mentioned as a possibility by baseball people that cover, then he'll spend upwards to 70 mil at least. 

In 6 years under Hoyer, hes gone over the Threshold twice, in 2024 and 2026, so, odds are pretty good that they stay under it again if there is one for 2027.

Why do I feel Hoyer is likely to wait ?

Because he has a history of waiting out the early asking prices of FA until they lower their ask. So, it would be unlike him to pounce on a FA early in the next 2 weeks that are looking for high dollars now before the deadline over waiting and getting guys that would consider accepting lower offers after its settled like I mentioned above. 

Now if he can nab a player or two willing to accept a low year low cost deal, then yea im sure he'll ink a deal, but I just dont see him inking a deal with anyone looking for years and money in next 2 weeks.

For the last couple years of my suggestions,  I bet I've been right or closer to being right then most who suggests all these players signed, high payroll, and trade scenarios 🤣

 

 

 

Very hard to say you are more right than others. Basically every year you predict little to no activity and yet when they do make moves you still claim to be right. Over the last few years they have traded for Tucker, signed Bregman, made several trades at the TDL while you thought none of that would happen, and yet somehow you claim to be be right. Even now, Jason explains they signed Stroman during the last lock out and you move goalposts. Most of your posts are very vague so you can basically make a case for anything they do being what you figured they would do. You actually have a skill of doing this. It allows you to come away suggesting you were right. 
Originally you suggested Hoyer would sit this out until after the lock out, because that is what he does. Jason showed you that isn’t what he did in the past so now that isn’t what you meant. Now they might sign a couple of players for 2 or 3 years before the lock out. That is a huge difference when you consider the Cubs might not sign anyone to more than. 3 years. Hell, the top pitchers after Skubal, might not get more than 3 years guaranteed. So basically by saying they will wait it out until after the lockout EXCEPT for signing guys at 3 or less years, you are creating a narrative that can’t be wrong. I believe you even said, except for the Japanese players who posted, as they would be the only ones who may sign for more than 4 years. So everything is covered. So nicely done. I am calling it now. You are right. Basically, because just like every year you can’t be wrong. You covered everything. 

North Side Contributor
Posted
22 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

That because Stroman accepted the 3 yr deal with an opt out after the 2nd year, the other top Starting pitchers were looking for 5 year deals.

Im not saying Hoyer wont sign anyone, just saying I dont expect him to sign anyone that looking for more than 2-3 years like Stroman did.

 

Now we're just moving goal posts. This is a direct quote from that post I responded to.

Quote

...it wouldn't surprise me if they waited until the lockout was over before acquiring anyone.

So to be fully clear you literally were. Now we've moved the goal posts from "acquiring anyone" to "anyone who accepts a three-year deal, not a five year one". Maybe the Cubs won't sign someone to five-years all offseason, a good reminder the Cubs have signed almost zero contracts over 5 years to begin with; just Swanson and Bregman as free agents. Does that also have to do with the CBA/lockout?

I think this is really more "pile on Jed" than it is anything. I do think the vibe we're getting is that the team's biggest spending may wait for post-CBA (Sharma and Mooney quickly shot down any Skubal hope, and the national winds have not included the Cubs as a team getting connections) but that's a Tom thing first and foremost as it's his budget. That would not be much a "that's what Hoyer does" thing. 

Verified Member
Posted

Side note, Wiggins is rule 5 eligible this year, Cubs have until Tuesday 6 pm ET to add him to the 40 man or he will be available in the rule 5 draft.  I think Cubs are at 34 of 40 right now. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
11 minutes ago, Nolo said:

Side note, Wiggins is rule 5 eligible this year, Cubs have until Tuesday 6 pm ET to add him to the 40 man or he will be available in the rule 5 draft.  I think Cubs are at 34 of 40 right now. 

They will add him. 

  • Like 1
Posted
42 minutes ago, Jason Ross said:

Now we're just moving goal posts. This is a direct quote from that post I responded to.

So to be fully clear you literally were. Now we've moved the goal posts from "acquiring anyone" to "anyone who accepts a three-year deal, not a five year one". Maybe the Cubs won't sign someone to five-years all offseason, a good reminder the Cubs have signed almost zero contracts over 5 years to begin with; just Swanson and Bregman as free agents. Does that also have to do with the CBA/lockout?

I think this is really more "pile on Jed" than it is anything. I do think the vibe we're getting is that the team's biggest spending may wait for post-CBA (Sharma and Mooney quickly shot down any Skubal hope, and the national winds have not included the Cubs as a team getting connections) but that's a Tom thing first and foremost as it's his budget. That would not be much a "that's what Hoyer does" thing. 

 Yea it wouldn't surprise me if he waited til the lockout was over to sign guys, doesn't mean that im saying that if a player was willing to accept a 1-3 year deal that he wouldn't do it. I even mentioned that in a response to a poster earlier today.

Whether its a Ricketts thing or Hoyer thing, They normally wait to see if asking prices come down before any agreement, so it would be out of the norm if Hoyer inks a guy quickly here in next 2 weeks that has more than 3 years at a cost.

 

 

Posted
56 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

Very hard to say you are more right than others. Basically every year you predict little to no activity and yet when they do make moves you still claim to be right. Over the last few years they have traded for Tucker, signed Bregman, made several trades at the TDL while you thought none of that would happen, and yet somehow you claim to be be right. Even now, Jason explains they signed Stroman during the last lock out and you move goalposts. Most of your posts are very vague so you can basically make a case for anything they do being what you figured they would do. You actually have a skill of doing this. It allows you to come away suggesting you were right. 
Originally you suggested Hoyer would sit this out until after the lock out, because that is what he does. Jason showed you that isn’t what he did in the past so now that isn’t what you meant. Now they might sign a couple of players for 2 or 3 years before the lock out. That is a huge difference when you consider the Cubs might not sign anyone to more than. 3 years. Hell, the top pitchers after Skubal, might not get more than 3 years guaranteed. So basically by saying they will wait it out until after the lockout EXCEPT for signing guys at 3 or less years, you are creating a narrative that can’t be wrong. I believe you even said, except for the Japanese players who posted, as they would be the only ones who may sign for more than 4 years. So everything is covered. So nicely done. I am calling it now. You are right. Basically, because just like every year you can’t be wrong. You covered everything. 

Lmao,  youre literally on here everyday suggesting they sign this guy, trade for that guy, cubs will spend,  cubs wont spend, making up scenarios every trade deadline and offseason,  and then when something else happens its, well we all knew that was coming 🤣🤣.

We all give opinions and share our thoughts on here, but you seem to think that if it doesn't match yours then their opinions are dumb and should be scrutinize by you, while yours, which has been pretty much way off most of the time just fades away cause nobody sits there like you do and goes back into your history to bring up your past posts so they can rag on you all the time. 

I bet you probably have printouts of posters posts just so you can go back to say they said this and that last year or years ago..lol.. I hardly remember most of my own posts just from recent ones,  let alone remember what other posters have said from previous years. 😅

Seriously dude, its a message board of strangers giving opinions and thoughts about their favorite team, not everyone going to agree which is great because you can discuss it if you want, but damn, you literally come at people and mostly me like it's your daily duty to try and discredit anything we say just cause you disagree. 

 

 

 

 

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
31 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

Lmao,  youre literally on here everyday suggesting they sign this guy, trade for that guy, cubs will spend,  cubs wont spend, making up scenarios every trade deadline and offseason,  and then when something else happens its, well we all knew that was coming 🤣🤣.

We all give opinions and share our thoughts on here, but you seem to think that if it doesn't match yours then their opinions are dumb and should be scrutinize by you, while yours, which has been pretty much way off most of the time just fades away cause nobody sits there like you do and goes back into your history to bring up your past posts so they can rag on you all the time. 

I bet you probably have printouts of posters posts just so you can go back to say they said this and that last year or years ago..lol.. I hardly remember most of my own posts just from recent ones,  let alone remember what other posters have said from previous years. 😅

Seriously dude, its a message board of strangers giving opinions and thoughts about their favorite team, not everyone going to agree which is great because you can discuss it if you want, but damn, you literally come at people and mostly me like it's your daily duty to try and discredit anything we say just cause you disagree. 

 

 

 

 

 

I didn’t point out where you were wrong suggesting it would be a Hoyer thing to wait until after the lock out to sign anyone. Jason did.  Then you moved the goal post. I also wasn’t the one to suggest I am right more often than most posters. You did. Seldom do I suggest I know what Hoyer will do. My posts are my opinions based on what I hope the Cubs will spend or direction they will take. Sure, as the off season moves on the opinions change. Sure, if my opinion is different than someone else’s I will make my argument why I think what I think. Everyone opinion changes as they hear from the FO what the plan is. And I have no issues with people who think different than me. The issue comes in when a poster suggests being right. Which is the only issue I have with anything you post. As I said, my guess is we all can pigeonhole moves made to fit our narrative. The difference is we don’t. Also, you are giving me way to much credit to suggest I print out posts or store them so I can come back later on them. Technology has past me by. I am done with this now. I shouldn’t have said what I said. 

Posted
14 minutes ago, Rcal10 said:

I didn’t point out where you were wrong suggesting it would be a Hoyer thing to wait until after the lock out to sign anyone. Jason did.  Then you moved the goal post. I also wasn’t the one to suggest I am right more often than most posters. You did. Seldom do I suggest I know what Hoyer will do. My posts are my opinions based on what I hope the Cubs will spend or direction they will take. Sure, as the off season moves on the opinions change. Sure, if my opinion is different than someone else’s I will make my argument why I think what I think. Everyone opinion changes as they hear from the FO what the plan is. And I have no issues with people who think different than me. The issue comes in when a poster suggests being right. Which is the only issue I have with anything you post. As I said, my guess is we all can pigeonhole moves made to fit our narrative. The difference is we don’t. Also, you are giving me way to much credit to suggest I print out posts or store them so I can come back later on them. Technology has past me by. I am done with this now. I shouldn’t have said what I said. 

I only said that cause you mentioned my suggestions, and as you see my laughing emoji, i was being funny.

Yes, he mentioned Stroman,  but as i mentioned,  Stroman took a low deal of 3 years with an opt out after year 2 instead of waiting like the other top SP did.

So, basically Hoyer got someone to bite on a team friendly deal before the deadline, can he do it again,  who knows, 2 weeks left.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
3 minutes ago, chibears55 said:

I only said that cause you mentioned my suggestions, and as you see my laughing emoji, i was being funny.

Yes, he mentioned Stroman,  but as i mentioned,  Stroman took a low deal of 3 years with an opt out after year 2 instead of waiting like the other top SP did.

So, basically Hoyer got someone to bite on a team friendly deal before the deadline, can he do it again,  who knows, 2 weeks left.

Honestly, aside from Taima, I don’t see the Cubs signing anyone for 4 or more years, before or after the lockout. MAYBE Rogers. I am not sure Peralta or King get 4 years. There are warts with them.band if they do, I don’t want it to be the Cubs anyway.  Seiya might get 4 years, and while I would be all for it, I doubt they sign him. Which is why, IMO, the lockout date is irrelevant. While Jed and the FO does have a pattern of waiting out the market on some guys they also have a pattern of jumping the market with others. Which leads me to believe anything is possible at any time.🤷

Posted
2 hours ago, Rcal10 said:

Honestly, aside from Taima, I don’t see the Cubs signing anyone for 4 or more years, before or after the lockout. MAYBE Rogers. I am not sure Peralta or King get 4 years. There are warts with them.band if they do, I don’t want it to be the Cubs anyway.  Seiya might get 4 years, and while I would be all for it, I doubt they sign him. Which is why, IMO, the lockout date is irrelevant. While Jed and the FO does have a pattern of waiting out the market on some guys they also have a pattern of jumping the market with others. Which leads me to believe anything is possible at any time.🤷

Hey Hoyer signed Taillon for 4 years, anything can happen.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

He had one incredible year in 24, they must think they can fix him

Seems like they gave up a couple of decent young(er) players for a guy they hope to fix.

Verified Member
Posted
12 minutes ago, Tangled Up in Plaid said:

He had one incredible year in 24, they must think they can fix him

Brewers don’t miss so I’m sure he’s going to give the Cubs hell next year 😂 

Posted
5 hours ago, Jason Ross said:

There's certainly going to have to be money for non-pitchers. That said I'm way out on Goldy. His xwOBA dipped heavy last year but his wOBA was well above it. Bat speed tanked hard. He's 39 and hitters simply do not last. 

You're probably buying more "Justin Turner" than anything. And these parts loved themselves some J-Turn.

chart (3).png

 

157 PAs against LHP 11 HR with 24 RBI with a slash line of .299/.393/.573 in 2026 with his slow bat speed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund
The North Side Baseball Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Cubs community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of North Side Baseball.

×
×
  • Create New...