Joe Morgan or Tim McCarver?

[Drew Doughty]

Who's worse?

 

Joe Morgan is there year-round, and that alone may make him worse, but Tim McCarver is extraordinarily bad. He's so bad, that even though he only announces on a national stage for half the season or so, he may be able to make up for the ground he loses in the first two months of the season.

 

Or maybe you hate someone else? Don't vote for Hawk seeing as how he is technically just a local announcer. I'm really only interested in national announcers.

[soccer10k]

Morgan for the reason you stated: he's on television regularly. McCarver's not.

[ConstableRabbit]

If McCarver was on as frequently, he's worse.

 

The worst is when McCarver and Buck do a Cubs-Cards Saturday game. Infuriating.

[Andy]

McCarver is worse, but he's also more fun to listen to. Morgan is more infuriating to listen to because we all know Dusty Baker agrees with most of what he says.

[Derwood]

i voted wrong. I thought it was a "who would you prefer" vs. "who's worse". I meant to say Morgan was worse.

[CubsBullsBears]

Morgan is horrible. It's worse when Joe Buck and McCarver do Cubs games. Joe Buck is such a Cardinals homer.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

They're both dumb. Joe Morgan's ignorance earns him my vote here.

[thedaymen]

Morgan may be on more, but I hear McCarver more as I'm more likely to watch a WS game then a Sunday night game.

[Derwood]

I'd like to point out that neither of these gentlmen is a Rock Band.

[Productive Outs]

I'd like to point out that neither of these gentlmen is a Rock Band.

 

they're solo acts.

[ResidentRoyalsFan]

Morgan doesn't understand statistics. McCarver doesnt understand anything. It's McCarver by a big big margin.

[Soul]

Morgan openly hates Sandberg, even going so far as to carry out a national campaign against him. Then he refused to show up at Ryno's Hall of Fame induction.

 

Morgan is a piece of crud.

 

I could care less about McCarver. But Morgan has my undying hate for ever and ever.

[TB_11]

If Morgan didn't have it out for Sandberg, I might say McCarver. The 2004 playoffs where he was openly rooting for the Yankees and Cardinals was borderline maddening.

 

But Morgan's hatred of Sandberg is absolutely unholy.