While I agree with everything you said, I don’t think bunting there was the right move. He should have been swinging. That said, I don’t think PCA attempting to bunt for a hit 5 times this year is a lot. It depends when he bunts. If no one is on base, bunting for a hit is a good idea. Doesn’t matter how many outs there are. If he can bunt to a .400 average that’s better than his actual BA. I realize bunting only gets him to first base, while swinging can get him extra bases. But if he does get a hit in a bunt he can always steal second base. Plus by bunting some, that puts the corner infielders in a little. Hell , might even put the 2nd baseman and SS in a little. Which gives him a better chance to get a ground ball through. As I said, the particular AB being discussed in the article, I agree bunting was not the move. But bunting should be a part of his game and with only 5 attempts this year, I don’t think he is bunting too much.