Things I Like
- I love Willi Castro for this team. Love love love. I would have taken him over any non-Cease rental arm. Pitching clearly didn't work out like I wanted but this was Plan A by a mile for me on the position player side
- I suspect the team added a lot of quality innings. Probably not impact innings, but quality innings
- There is a certain extent to which it's nice to push the Caissie/Alcantara decision until after the Tucker situation is resolved
- I prefer the second reliever addition to an Adrian Houser type rotation arm
- Probably grasping at straws, but is the lack of another SP a signal that we've all been overestimating Horton's innings restrictions? If the team thinks it can get closer to 150 innings out of him while we've been earmarking 120, it changes the calculus quite a bit
- I am glad the team did not sell low on Brown or Wicks
Things I don't Like
- Jameson Taillon’s our 3rd starter in the playoffs...cool
- The reason I accepted not making another SP move last winter was an expectation that powder was being kept dry for this summer. Well that powder's still bone dry, so how many more times are we going to kick this can down the road?
- Owen Caissie's going to enter the winter with ~1100 AAA plate appearances. Ballesteros around 800. Alcantara's last option year is next year. What's the endgame here?
- If SP prices were too exhorbitant, the team should have aimed higher on the RP front. I would have gladly done the deals the Yankees did for Bednar or Doval for instance
- If the division was comfortably in hand, I would like taking a lighter touch on SP additions in order to give runway to Brown/Wicks. But the division VERY MUCH IS NOT in hand