DeWitt is an upgrade over Theriot. The key to whether the trade was good is how the two prospects develop. If they become good major leaguers, it was a good deal. If they flame out, it was a poor trade. And so far, as has been said, the Bradley for Silva deal has had good results. The trade may have been a bad idea, but it's worked out so far. not really. They've got a fat heartcase on their hands that can't be counted on for anything but almost has to be given a spot. Silva certainly contributed more than Bradley would have in 2010 and with the extra money they signed Byrd. I don't know how anyone can knock that deal. As for 2011, we will have to see what happens. I don't know how anybody can give "points" to Hendry for the deal. He put himself in a crappy situation. There aren't points awarded for theoretical wins based on deals. The Cubs have a fat heartcase on the roster with a ridiculously inconsistent track record. They didn't win anything.