If everyone is healthy and performs to their capabilities, the rotation should be Z, Prior, Hill, Lilly, Marquis. Miller moves to the bullpen for long relief, or as a fill-in starter when someone misses a start. Ideally we would move Dempster, due to his contract and his shakiness last year. Howry and Eyre are scheduled to get similar pay, but they pitched well last year and should stay on. Even though we just picked up Cotts, his performance suggests he should be the next to go if we wanted to drop to 11 pitchers. Rotation: Z, Prior, Hill, Lilly, Marquis Bullpen: Miller (long-relief), Ohman, Wuertz, Howry, Eyre, Wood (closer) That's the ideal situation. The fact is that not everyone is going to be healthy, meaning Miller or Marshall/Mateo/Marmol may be competing for the fifth rotation spot, and Dempster and Cotts may be needed for relief work, especially if Piniella wants to keep 12 pitchers.