I think we've all had it with Corey/Neifi going 1-2 in the order. I thought it might be interesting to look at the top five guys in NL RBI and their plate appearances split with runners on, so we can put some numbers on how few opportunities Derrek has had to knock people in:
PAs* PAs w/ men on % RBI w/ runners on RBI/(PA w/men on)
C Lee 345 182 52.8 63 .36
D Lee 347 140 40.3 54 .39
Pujols 361 171 47.4 55 .32
Burrell 309 171 55.3 54 .32
A Jones 338 178 52.7 44 .25
PAs* are ABs + walks + HBP, I don't have PAs from sacrifices in here Out of all the leading NL RBI guys, Derrek has had by far the least amount of PA*s with men on, while still driving in guys at the same (if not slightly better) rate than everybody else. Here's the same analysis, now done for PA*s with guys in scoring position:
PAs* PAs w/ RISP % RBI w/ RISP RBI/(PA w/RISP)
C Lee 345 113 32.8 55 .49
D Lee 347 94 27.1 49 .52
Pujols 361 103 28.5 46 .45
Burrell 309 104 33.7 49 .47
A Jones 338 111 32.8 28 .25
Again, we see the same effect, although it is a little more muted here - Derrek has had fewer PA*s with men in scoring position, but has taken advantage of those PA*s at a rate on par or better than the rest of the NL RBI guys. It's pretty obvious Neifi/Corey going 1-2 is not helping our cause at all, and any benefit from having Walker bat toward the bottom of the order for protection is being negated by not having anyone for Derrek to knock in. Our chances of scoring runs and winning games, as well as one of the great Cubs seasons in history is being muted because of the lineup and our manager. Others thoughts?