Girardi may end up being my default selection, since I would prefer him over Piniella who seems to be getting the most buzz in media circles. I was most interested in Fredi Gonzalez, but he may be hired before Hendry makes a phone call to him. I have friends who greatly prefer Girardi. I have heard your list, CubinNY, but I'll take it and expand it with the rationale I've heard. 1. He use to play for the Cubs He "gets" the Cubs, Wrigley Field and Cubs fans in a way that previous managers have not. Bruce Miles wrote an excellent article a few days ago about how Dusty never seemed to warm to Chicago or to Cubs fans (one telling detail was how Dusty often wore his watch set to Pacific Time). Girardi knows that it can be really cold in April; that the park plays differently depending on the wind; that Cubs fans will usually show up, even if it is to boo; that day games aren't an excuse for losing even if they've been used that way too often. Girardi was also a team captain with the Cubs (insert obligatory comment about how he deserved to be team captain) and the union rep, at least in '02, so he had a team leadership role while he played. Anyone who remembers watching Cubs games during Girardi's tenure will recall many comments about how he'd make a fine manager someday, so in a sense we've been programmed for years into accepting him as a manager. 2. He went to Northwestern The first observation (which NW alums would love) seems to be that this means he is really smart. And he has an engineering degree, I believe, so that's further evidence! Just think of the intellect that could be on display during Cards-Cubs games. Second is that he has strong local roots. He'd be committed to the Cubs managerial job because of that. The Cubs gig is and should be a coveted job ... but ... if you're seeking a 'name' manager, which Hendry may well be doing, then you have to anticipate that a Big Name may have Higher Aspirations than the job you're offering. One concern with Piniella is that he'd just be biding time until the Yankees job opened up. Because of his local history, people don't think that would be a concern with Girardi. 3. He was the Yankees bench coach I heard this cited more when he was available before being hired by the Marlins (when some hoped the Cubs would swoop in and hire him then), and that was to compensate for his then-lack-of managerial experience. The followup observations are that the Yankees emphasize running a professional clubhouse and that one learns to interact with the media if one serves in any capacity with the NYY. I've also heard: He was a catcher and catchers tend to make good managers He had to play young players / rooks in Florida and he won (comparatively speaking) with them He continued to manage well in Florida despite the messy situation there and the rumors he was fired mid-season He knows how to construct a lineup