Well, I find it humorous that you refer to Patterson's .263 average seemingly to say he had a mediocre year, but then you use IsoD later in the post. As you probably know, batting average is a really lousy stat to evaluate a player's performance. And by the way, he hit .358 at Iowa. As for AFL, he ranked in the top 10 in BA (there's that stat again!), OBP and OPS, so regardless of it being a hitter's league, he was one of the best players in the league. And, it should be noted that the Southern League traditionally favors pitchers. I don't think I need to do much to say that Patterson had a mediocre year in the SL. His final line was .263/.330/.408 to go along with average at best defense. While I do like Patterson, I just don't see what he has done that justifies drooling over him joining the lineup in 2008. His .358 at Iowa was impressive but it came in only 60 some at bats so I don't think you can use that to form much of an opinion. Patterson definately has more leadoff potential than Pie and definately has a better shot of reaching his upside but Pie's ceiling is so much higher than Patterson's.