Seiya Suzuki, Trade Candidate? Landing Spots and Potential Returns for Cubs Slugger

[Paul Niemiec]

Image courtesy of © Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images

Mother Nature and the Chicago Cubs seem to think otherwise, but we are in the midst of summer. The Fourth of July is around the corner and the Cubs currently sit at 41-37, 7.5 games out of first in the NL Central. They're tied with the Padres for the final Wild Card spot, narrowly behind the Cardinals and Phillies for the top two berths and barely ahead of the Nationals and Marlins. The early season juggernaut has been crippled by pitching injuries and extended slumps from their offensive stars not named Pete Crow-Armstrong.  

The good news is that Matthew Boyd is nearly ready to go again, and that Crow-Armstrong leads baseball (non-Ohtani division) in wins above replacement. The bad news is that Edward Cabrera went down with a bad hamstring strain on Tuesday night in Queens, and could be lost for quite a while. 

More bad news is that the Cubs’ next three matchups after this tussle with the Mets are against Milwaukee, San Diego and St. Louis. The time to gain some ground was earlier this month, but they could barely tread water, going 6-6 against Colorado and San Francisco. Technically, facing these three teams is an opportunity to make up for lost time. Non-technically, the team is only now sloshing back into form, and the pitching staff feels way too thin to get them through such a crucial stretch right on the heels of playing four games in three days in New York.

The Cubs offense looked great over the weekend at home against the Blue Jays. We hope this is a turning point and they can start mashing themselves into frequent wins again, but their struggles of late have gotten the rumor mill turning. One player often mentioned is right fielder and designated hitter Seiya Suzuki, who's in the last year of his contract and is slashing .269/.348/.445, with 10 homers and 1.7 fWAR. If the Cubs do decide to trade him in either a move to re-tool for next season, or a creative trade to acquire pitching for this season, he would be one of the top right-handed bats on the market. The Cubs, hopefully, will be in a position where they can demand a decent return, but he won't fetch any top-tier prospects. Here are five teams who would make solid trade partners if the Cubs do decide to explore a deal.

Padres 
Another early season powerhouse who has fallen back to earth after a terrific April, the Padres have not been getting the results they're paying for from their star players. Xander Bogaerts has a .659 OPS, Jackson Merrill’s is .631, Fernando Tatis Jr. only has two home runs, and Manny Machado has 14 bombs but is hitting only .185. Tatis has been filling in at second base for the injured Jake Cronenworth, leaving two revolving doors in the outfield next to Merrill, because Ramón Laureano is on the 60-day IL. The Padres are currently playing Jase Bowen and Samad Taylor nearly every day. [Editor's note: I had to check, too, but no, he's not making up Jase Bowen. That's a real person.] While Taylor has hit well, Lord (not Brad) knows how sustainable that is. Although Suzuki has gone through his own struggles this season, his arrival would immediately take some pressure off their underperforming stars and provide some much-needed right-handed pop. 

As for a return, the Cubs should not be asking for teenagers or low-level lottery ticket guys. Anything they get for Suzuki should help them in the very near term. The problem is that the Padres’ top prospect list is littered with players in the low minors. An interesting name is right-handed reliever Garrett Hawkins, who has a mid-90s fastball with significant movement. He's still working on developing a consistent secondary pitch. He will issue walks but profiles as a big-league reliever, should he continue to make adjustments. The Padres might also be willing to part with a reliever on their big-league roster in order to help out the offense. The 22-year-old Bradgley Rodriguez is a high-upside, controllable piece, although that might make him the toughest to acquire. Adrian Morejon or Ron Marinaccio are both having good, but not great, seasons and could be a target for the Cubs, as well. Trading Suzuki for nothing but relief help would hit like a jab to the ribs, but since the Cubs have failed to develop their own pipeline of talented arms, they're going to have to overpay for some, one way or another.

Phillies
As is true with the Padres, the Cubs may be hesitant to move Suzuki to a team they hope to be directly competing with in the Wild Card race, but what if the team that sits dead last in outfielder fWAR makes them an offer they can’t refuse? The Phillies acquired reserve outfielder Derek Hill from the White Sox last week, which shows their desperation to find any workable solution. Adolis Garcóa is now on the 60-day IL, which leaves them with rookie Justin Crawford, who has been disappointing. Luckily, Brandon Marsh is having the best season of his career with 10 homers and an .833 OPS, but their lefty-heavy lineup needs some support from the right side.

Could the Cubs ask for an outfielder in return? Gabriel Rincones Jr. is currently on the Phillies’ major-league roster, but is 1-19 and would benefit from more time in the minors. The Cubs have enough outfield depth options to afford to send Rincones back to the minors even after a Suzuki trade; Matt Shaw would take over in right. If the 25-year-old is able to tap into his raw power consistently, he could become a 30+ home run threat. That's not that likely, given how slowly he's developed, but he could be one piece in a deal.

The closer for the Double-A Reading Phillies, Alex McFarlane, has a 2.08 ERA across 26 innings and has a fastball-slider combo that can play in the big leagues this season. Young righty Moisés Chace is another interesting option. He is recovering from Tommy John surgery, but he has a full arsenal of effective pitches. His mid-90s fastball, combined with a sweeper, changeup, and cutter, give Chace a reliever floor with potential starter upside. He could break into the big leagues next season.

Yankees
A decade after the Cubs and Yankees pulled off the biggest blockbuster of 2016, could they be in a position to do it again this season? Well, not exactly. A Suzuki trade would not be considered a blockbuster, but the Yankees are in need of outfield help with Aaron Judge down for a significant portion of the summer. With Giancarlo Stanton and Trent Grisham joining Judge on the IL, Cody Bellinger is sharing outfield duties with Jasson Dominguez and sub-.700 OPS, light-hitting utility player Max Schuemann, and extremely flawed, (technically) extremely talented quasi-prospect Spencer Jones. The Yankees are another team whose lineup leans very left-handed, especially while missing Judge and Stanton. The 38-year-old Paul Goldschmidt is playing like an All-Star again, but only in a very limited role. He is nearly the entirety of the team’s right-handed production. 

The Yankees’ farm system is littered with pitching, even if Elmer Rodriguez and Carlos Lagrange are off the table. Their 2024 first rounder, Ben Hess, could be an intriguing name for the Cubs to target. The burly 6-foot-5 righthander has drawn comparisons to Lance Lynn, but control issues have kept him from reaching his full potential. He has issued 16 walks in 21 2/3 innings in Double-A this season. With Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón, and Max Fried under large contracts, Cam Schlittler emerging as one of the top arms in the game, and guys like Will Warren and Ryan Weathers in the fold, the Yankees may not see a path to the majors for Hess. One last name to think of here is 2024 AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil. Since winning the award, he has dealt with ineffectiveness and injuries, making him a great change of scenery candidate. 

Guardians
Now that their lineup is missing all three of José Ramírez, Chase DeLauter, and Angel Martínez, it's safe to say they have the worst lineup in baseball. Even when they were healthy, their offense really wasn't anything for opposing pitchers to worry about. They are 23rd in wRC+, 25th in home runs, and 26th in runs scored. Rookie Travis Bazzana is doing all he can, as he is now the default best hitter on the team, but the punch is basically nonexistent. Steven Kwan is in the worst slump of his career, which began last season, and the right-handed power bat is the ghost of Rhys Hoskins. With all due respect to David Fry, Petey Halpin and Stuart Fairchild, they need another competent hitter in the outfield if they want to gain any significant ground on the White Sox and the suddenly surging Tigers. Traditionally, the Guardians’ pitching is what carries them through the season until their inevitable October demise, but if they are serious about making noise in the playoffs, they need a right-handed bat. 

With the bullpen being a big strength of this team, anchored by closer Cade Smith, they may be willing to part with a reliever on the major-league roster as well as a mid-range prospect. Veteran righties Colin Holderman and Shawn Armstrong are having strong seasons, as is lefty Erik Sabrowski. It would be fair for the Cubs to ask for one of these guys in return, but if they want to add another outfielder, they can target 21-year-old Jaison Chourio, the younger brother of Jackson. He had a down year in 2025 which caused him to drop off the back end of top-100 prospect lists, but he has a .942 OPS with Double-A Arkansas this season and should be worthy of a major-league look sometime in 2027. This is the kind of player the Guardians usually hate to move, but with the number of suitors for Suzuki, the Cubs can afford to force Cleveland to pay up. 

Blue Jays
The Blue Jays have a nice little outfield of Nathan Lukes, Jesús Sánchez, and Daulton Varsho, but the nearly 37-year-old George Springer is probably best left as a platoon player, rather than the primary DH for a team trying to defend the AL title—even if he is second on the team in home runs, with eight. The Yankees and Rays are both legit contenders, so the Blue Jays can’t afford to sit around and hope Vladimir Guerrero Jr. starts to hit with power again. They have also been without a healthy Addison Barger for most of the season, so rookie Yohendrick Piñango (old friend alert!) had been a major piece of their roster before he was optioned this week. He was hitting .283 with a .764 OPS, good enough to be a table setter, but would hardly scare a pitching staff in the postseason. The Blue Jays wouldn’t be in this conversation if Anthony Santander, who signed a five-year deal before last season, was dependable. There are reports that he is working his way back, but he was awful in the 54 games he played last season, slashing .175/.271/.294. The point is, it would make the most sense for Toronto to be aggressive as anyone in a Suzuki pursuit.

The Blue Jays have a strong farm system that is loaded with high-upside arms like Johnny King, Ricky Tiedemann, and Gage Stanifer, but with an aging rotation at the big-league level, they might not feel inclined to trade from that bunch. However, they have a 25-year-old righty named Jake Bloss who touches the high 90s on his fastball and boasts a curveball/slider combo that could work great in a bullpen role. He is currently recovering from elbow surgery, but is expected to be back this season. Depending on the handedness the Cubs are looking for, lefty Mason Fluharty and righty Spencer Miles have FIPs under 3.40 and come with years of team control, so either one of them could be a fair ask, along with Bloss. If they’re looking for a throw-in player with some upside and positional versatility, Charles McAdoo was also just sent down. He can play first, third, and the corner outfield spots and can turn into a nice right-handed bench bat or even a starting option in right.

View full article

[Justspittintruths]

Chourio is about the only somewhat intriguing name in there. And if the number of supposed suitors can force the Guardians to pay up, then why are the rest of the ideas centered around bending the Cubs over the other teams dumpsters and doing them dry?

[Outshined_One]

I had a Mean Girls-like post ready to go in response to this one, but now the Cubs' rotation consists of a handful of malfunctioning pitching machines, Rea, and Assad.

Time to blow it up!