Better Pitcher: Bob Gibson or Roger Clemens

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Saw this poll on another site, and unbelievably it's a lot closer than I thought it should be.

 

You can look at the player's stats and qualifications at baseball-reference.com or baseballhalloffame.org.

 

Feel free to make your case. I'd just like to compare the results here to those elsewhere.

[Omar]

Clemens has pretty similer statistics.. but he did it in more of a hitters era. Unless he took steroids, my vote goes for him.

[Omar]

Clemens has pretty similer statistics.. but he did it in more of a hitters era. Unless he took steroids, my vote goes for him.

[CuseCubFan69]

If I wanted to win one game between the 2 it would be Gibson.

[TruffleShuffle]

I hate the guy, but it's Clemens and it's not even very close.

[soccer10k]

I hate the guy, but it's Clemens and it's not even very close.

 

Agreed.

[MPrior]

I hate the guy, but it's Clemens and it's not even very close.

 

Agreed.

 

Thirded.

[wekse]

Clemens

[TruffleShuffle]

No shock, Bob Gibson beat Roger Clemens on the Cards' board. Good thing they aren't HoF voters over there!

[Balsa]

Clemens by far. He played in a much tougher era.

[imb]

Clemens without a doubt. 6 MVP top tens and seven cy youngs? Something like 13 seasons with an era+ over 140? Clemens may be the best pitcher of all time, Gibson might crack the top ten.

[wolf stansson]

Mos def RC.