What's the point in giving Troy or Temple a shot? What's the benefit? The fact that basketball does it is hardly justification. The minute you start handing out invites to every conf champ, is the minute you reduce the incentive for teams to schedule tough OOC games. A tough OOC schedule not only increases your odds of losing that game, but it can hurt you the rest of the year. Nobody wants to see Florida, LSU, USC or OSU playing Central Michigan or BYU in December. And that is part of the reason why this won't work. And why should it happen? Because you say so? I think people need to get away from the "should" talk, as it's going to get you no where. Come up with a system that would work (ie, satisfy all participants economic interests), and you might have something. But simply being a D1 school doesn't guarantee you a shot at the national football title. There's no inherent right to such a thing. Schools that want to contend for a title invest in their program and take the necessary steps to make it possible. And before we get into the complaints about money getting in the way of what's right, stop. There aren't many successful ventures in this world, and especially in this country, that don't take economic factors into account. If we want big exciting matchups available for our viewing pleasure in various formats, you're going to have to just deal with the fact that money plays a huge role here. I just generally disagree with your whole philosophy on this goony. What's the point of fielding a team that isn't allowed to compete for a Championship? What other sport does that? Forget college basketball...what other sport, professional, college, or otherwise, provides no opportunity for an undefeated team to have a shot at the championship? No other sport manages to let money get in the way of every team having an opportunity. Why should it happen? Because you can't definitively tell me that Florida is the National Champion. Because this argument is taking place is the exact reason why something needs to happen to make a change. I understand money plays a huge role, and that's why those conferences would have to get an automatic bid somehow into whatever tournament was decided to be implemented. But just because Boise State gets into a tournament doesn't mean you aren't going to have "big exciting matchups." I don't know about you, but the BSU-Oklahoma game was a HELL of a lot more exciting than last nights snoozer. I fundamentally disagree with you here. Yes, being a D1 school should guarantee you a chance at a title. It defies the entire idea of "sport" to not have that opportunity. Why play if you can't win? So you don't like the crumbs off the ground? The BSU-OK game would have had even more excitement if it meant the winner moves on in the playoffs.