Jump to content
Our first free agents ranking has launched, click here to see the top 40+ names in free agency! ×
North Side Baseball

Bertz

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    13,444

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    39

 Content Type 

Profiles

Joomla Posts 1

Chicago Cubs Videos

Chicago Cubs Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

2026 Chicago Cubs Top Prospects Ranking

News

2023 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

Guides & Resources

2024 Chicago Cubs Draft Picks

The Chicago Cubs Players Project

2025 Chicago Cubs Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Chicago Cubs Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Blogs

Events

Forums

Store

Gallery

Everything posted by Bertz

  1. Bertz
    Thinking through this a bit more, in my mind: - You've got to pull down one of the lefties or one of the more primo trade targets. I like Bieber and think he's become underrated but you can't grab him and then declare mission accomplished on the SP front - You pretty much need to pull down one of Chapman/Bellinger. CF, 3B, and #5 SP are spots on the roster that I look at and think "It'll probably be fine?" But one of the costs of foregoing a true star like Soto is you can't have two many of those landmine type positions lying around. If you're not addressing the pitching one you damn sure need to address one, ideally both, of the offensive ones - This would seem to increase the odds Morel sticks around? Most of the hypothetical Morel trades were to add a second, less expensive SP. Not that you can't do Cease, Valdez, or Luzardo and include Morel, but it seems much less likely than just signing Imanaga or Montgomery - Adding two RPs makes it that much more likely one of them is like a boring Phil Maton/Brent Suter type. Let me just go on record right now about how much I hate adding that type of reliever this winter. Relief help should either be impact types or have minor league options, no exceptions
  2. Bertz
    You would presume if Tommy is saying this on the radio then this is the plan. A bit of a shame because I have preferred a two SP plan since we missed on the elite bats.
  3. Bertz
    Sounds like they are probably gonna be wrapped up after they close a deal with Joc Pederson.
  4. Bertz
    Yeah I think even if Hader gets to a price where Jed can stomach the dollars he's not going to give up the pick. There was talk Jed is willing to stretch out of his RP comfort zone in deference to Counsell. But I think that tops out at $20-40M for Robert Stephenson or Jordan Hicks or someone like that.
  5. Bertz
    I mean your Day 1 qualifier changes quite a bit. If you take that away I think most signings we've had word of well ahead of time. Like last year Taillon was more or less out of nowhere but I think everyone else we had pretty decent runway knowing they were being pursued.
  6. Bertz
    Thinking out loud, if you pulled down Alonso, Imanaga, and traded for Jansen with Boston covering ~half his salary, you would have filled the three biggest holes on the roster with legit 1st division talents. You'd also, we suspect, have $20-30M more to play with. You could at that point more confidently play a game of chicken with Boras for Chapman/Bellinger, do the Bieber/Naylor deal, or build Counsell a bullpen of doom with e.g Robertson + Stephenson.
  7. Bertz
    I believe Sharma mentioned him on TV over the holiday and it was the first time I'd heard his name basically since Stearns took over. He is the one guy who seems realistically available in that hitter-tier in between Soto/Ohtani and like Rhys Hoskins.
  8. Bertz
    Once again someone who's in the know is like "oh yeah they're definitely gonna make some trades". And this time specifically it's mentioned on the offensive side. Really curious if it's the usual suspects we've been discussing, or if it's anyone a little more off the radar.
  9. Bertz
    I think a lot of the conservative action around not starting high pick QBs early is worry they'll get themselves killed. Williams/Maye are pretty polished, plus the unique circumstances of the Bears' roster would have this as one of the best rookie QB supporting casts of all time. I'm very understanding of giving rookies ~6 weeks behind a vet before handing them the keys, but I don't think it'll be necessary here.
  10. Bertz
    Move the Reds from "probably done" to "definitely done"
  11. Bertz
    I still tend to think the team would have crossed the LT threshold last year if the plan was not to this year. The marginal value of even just an additional ~$10M was extremely high last offseason. At the deadline another 3-5 would have made a more substantial relief upgrade pretty easy. Even for someone as conservative as Jed I don't think you leave that on the table just for the ~20% chance you come down with Ohtani.
  12. Bertz
    I wasn't really buying Murray this time last year. As you get into in the video the tools are all average or a smudge below, and I chalked up the sterling production to beating up on kids. Most reports also had him fringey at best at 3rd. But this year he carried his offense up to AA without missing a beat, SUBSTANTIALLY dropped his groundball rate without adding any swing and miss, and now his defense is viewed as pretty average at 3B. All that from a true switch hitter (he has negligible lefty/righty splits) and I'm really big on Murray.
  13. Bertz
    Jed's done a really good job of bringing in well credentialed voices from multiple different orgs and GM trees. Like I'd love to poach some Twins/Mariners folks at some point but broadly I would be surprised if the org falls way behind in any area given how actively they are cycling in new blood from smart orgs. The Theo era had a lot of Boston retreads. They generally seemed to be smart folks but if every single person has that Theo throughline you're still missing something.
  14. Bertz
    I think for both Bellinger and Chapman their options look like Cubs, hope the Mariners secretly have money, hope the Angels are willing to spend to paper over the embarrassment of the Ohtani debacle, or hope the Tigers or someone else from that group decide to play mystery team. Never count out Boras but honestly it looks bad for him right now.
  15. Bertz
    Right, I'm saying I agree he had two INTs that shouldn't really be held against him, but he separately had two should-have-been INTs dropped by the defense so it's all a wash.
  16. Bertz
    Didn't he have two passes hit defenders in the hands and get dropped? I remember karma more or less working out for that game.
  17. Bertz
    Yup. And I think it does a certain amount of separating out WR performance from QB performance. I would guess that's why even the recent numbers are fairly pedestrian is a lot of this production has been DJ Moore generated.
  18. Bertz
    Fields since coming back from injury has QBRs for each game of 72.0 41.6 65.7 18.0 64.0 66.0 Average those out and you get 54.6 (technically I should weight these by dropbacks but that's more work than I'm willing to do right now and would only change the number a smidge). If that was Justin's full season QBR he'd rank 17th in the NFL between Mayfield and Stroud. In the same neighborhood as Goff, Lawrence, and Carr. So even in the best stretch of Fields' career he's been slightly above average? I feel like the arrow is still pointing up a bit, and if we didn't have the Panthers pick I'd be happy to continue building around Fields. But we do have that pick, so IMO the only reason to keep riding with Justin is because of the Bears' sad QB history and fear of the unknown.
  19. Bertz
    Despite the calendar and the grousing, the offseason is pretty young. 6 of MLBTR's top 10 FAs are still on the board, 10 of the top 20, and 28 of the top 50. Last year 41 of MLBTR's top 50 had signed by New Years, and Andrew Benintendi at #15 was the top rated player unsigned. If you look around the league though, there does not look to be a lot of demand, so the situation might not change very quickly. The Giants and Yankees are signaling they are likely to pull down high-end SPs, but everyone else is indicating they're focused mid-market or lower. I've gone through each non-Cub team below based on what's out there for them (or failing that their history), and it very much looks like a lot of the same (in quotes to avoid endless scrolling) We'll see what Jed does with his opportunity, but at this moment waiting out the market looks like it could pay off.
  20. Bertz
    In my mind a Matt Chapman reunion still seemed pretty likely before reading this. I'm a bit nervous on the pitching front, but things are playing out for Jed to absolutely clean up on the position player front.
  21. Bertz
    Red Sox do not appear to be shopping top of market
  22. Bertz
    None of these feel like a good idea. Maybe the last one if it's some sort of complicated swell-opt or something, but even then probably no. I'm extremely into Bellinger on something like Carlos Correa's first deal with the Twins (3-4 years, high AAV, opt-outs after every year), but not really under any sort of long term deal. Relatedly, I think history is going to look back at AJ Preller's '22-'23 offseason as just an unmitigated disaster, nearly as bad as his very first one where he traded every prospect with a pulse for Matt Kemp et al. Giving decade+ long deals to guys outside of the Harper/Machado/Seager class of FA's is so unbelievably dumb. The early extensions to Machado and Darvish being a mess was easy to see coming as well.
  23. Bertz
    Is it? Because if you look at the MLBTR free agent predictions https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2023/11/2023-24-top-50-free-agents-with-predictions.html Yamamoto and Lee absolutely destroyed expectations, and most everyone else has come in at or under.
  24. Bertz
    Okay yeah I think they're planning to grab Cease
  25. Bertz
    He's very much an "it depends on what's added around him" type for me but I've definitely eyed him.
×
×
  • Create New...