The lack of swing and miss is something I think is worth worrying about a bit, but the rest feels like regular ebbs and flows stuff.
Hendricks stuff isn't down, in fact it's actually up a bit. The velo is the best it's been since 2016, and the Stuff metrics don't go back that far but agree the stuff is up YoY. He's not throwing more pitches down the middle, his "Meatball" rate is below his career average and his "Edge" rate is a smidge below his career number but up over last year and well above the league number.
I would say there are three things going on here, with mileage varying on how they should be weighted:
- Horsefeathers happens. It's just three games
- The schedule. He faced an elite offense and two other good ones, with two of those starts on the road. That's a tough gauntlet for anyone
- Predictability. This is my best guess as to where something actually need to be done. Maybe he's tipping pitches, maybe his sequencing has been too predictable, or maybe (and this is my personal guess) he needs to bump his curveball usage up to something closer to 10%. But a lot of the worst damage this year has been done on pitches that weren't actually that bad. Watching him, particularly yesterday, has felt like playing MLB The Show with Guess Pitch turned on