This lineup would also look good if we got Andruw Jones: 1b: Lee 2b: Neifi Perez SS: Izturis 3b: Ramirez LF: Murton CF: Jones RF: Jones C: Barrett Either way, we'd still have a huge hole So you don't think those lineups are capable of scoring runs and aren't playoff quality lineups? No, I think those lineups are capable of scoring runs, but with potentially three holes in the lineup (2B, SS, P) - they probably won't score enough. Combine that with average or below average pitching, and you've got problems. You can't cite the pitchers spot as a gaping hole because there is no better option. The Cubs are in the NL. The pitcher has to bat. How do you know the Cubs will ave "average or below average pitching" as well? You don't. That lineup plus a decent rotation (depending on who they pick up) equals a contending team. I'm describing the Cubs pitching as average or below average because that's what it is right now - and I can't see it changing in the near future, barring significant moves. If we want Andruw Jones, we'll have to trade for him, and we'll probably trade some of our young pitchers away, thus reducing our depth even further. I could play your game and say that a team of 1B Lee 2B Below average player SS Below average player 3B Ramirez LF Murton CF Jones RF Jones C Barrett SP Zambrano SP Zito SP Prior SP Liriano SP Carpenter is good too, but that's projecting too much now isn't it? Yup, that's my game right there. Unrealistic offseason moves. You hit it right on the head. I believe I stated "decent rotation" not "all-star rotation". We are a major market team. There is no reason we shouldn't be able to add a big bat and a solid starter to the rotation in the offseason.