I disagree, I actually think it was an awful trade by the Giants. Sanchez likely didn't have much value, but he still has some upside and if he can get his control together he could be pretty useful. I have no problem shopping him around and trying to deal him, but if Melky was the best they could do, I'd have kept him. Melky had a bit of a breakout year last year, but prior to that had amassed 3.5 WAR in 6 MLB seasons (5 full). His highest slugging was .416 and his highest OBP was .336. Defensively, he's posted UZR/150s (career) of .5 in LF, -7.3 in CF, and 1.5 in RF. He did break out a bit this year, but that only amounted to an .809 OPS with a still poor .339 OBP. During this breakout year, his BABIP was 40 points higher than his career average and his HR/FB ratio was the second highest of his career (9.8%). It could be a breakout year as he enters his prime, or it could be a normal season fueled by luck. It appears to me to be the latter and, if so, the Giants just gave up a lefty with some potential left for a hitter who's been bad in the minors and majors and then was overhyped by the Yankees. You have to imagine his numbers are going to take a significant, possibly huge hit going from Kauffman to AT&T Park. And I'd imagine his defense will be a bit more exposed. I really like this deal for the Royals, and it looks like another ill-advised move by Brian Sabean. I think they could have gotten more for Sanchez.