Both are FAs, so previous salaries dictate little as far as future contracts. I think Lilly will get more per year than Padilla b/c once Daisuke, Zito, and Schmidt all sign, I think Lilly will be in demand moreso than Padilla and rec. a higher salary. As far as stuff, despite that awkward BP stat, I'd rate Padilla's FB and change better, while his slider is just as good as Lilly's curve. The problem with Padilla has been the ability to maintain it. Given that Lilly will probably get a couple mil more per year, IMO, Padilla will be worth more.