Hoerner (R)
PCA (L)
Seiya (R)
Tucker (L)
Kelly (R)
Busch (L)
Swanson (R)
Happ (S)
Shaw (R)
Maybe you switch Tucker and keep him where he's been all year because even slumping he still takes good ABs and gets on base, but PCA brings speed
I dunno, maybe that's stupid. If every one of your hitters is slumping at the same time nothing looks great