i mean this is usually a pretty winning strategy, given the Bucs terrible record of tinkering too much with pitchers It's a great strategy if you're the A's or the Twins, not if you're a major market team in the last year of their offensive core window Of course, that would mean not trading Darvish either, but here we are Joe Musgrove is working out great for the win-now Padres who have spent a ton of money the last 2 years. Jameson Taillon hasnt worked out so far but the Yankees invested in him. Gerrit Cole helped the Astros win a pennant The Rays are small market so it doesnt match your criteria but Tyler Glasnow is another example of a talented Pirates pitcher who was rehabbed and became an elite pitcher who pitched in the World Series last year. Why wouldn't you take advantage of that? I get your point we shouldn't be relying on scrapheap guys while trading away guys like Darvish but the Pirates in particular have been ripe with talented pitchers that are turned around on a different team.