Yes, in fact, he is terrible. In a recent Baseball Prospectus article, he appeared as the #12 worst offensive baseball player since 1900. He is an ideal late-innings replacement or backup shortstop, but he shouldn't be starting. I don't think anyone here hates him - it's not that he kicks babies or eats puppies - but, like lots here say, I hate the way Dusty uses him. Neifi shouldn't start, but when he does, he shouldn't be anywhere near the 2 slot. The problem with BPRO's statement is people misinterpret it. It by no means is saying Neifi is the 12th worst player at offense in baseball's history. It is saying that he has cost teams the 12th most offensively in baseball history. That is to say, he's managed to accumulate enough PAs over the years that his offense has been the 12th most detrimental of all time. There have been 1000s of players in history who were worse offensively.