How could he have done a lot worse? Whether Johnson hits a sac fly or strikes out there, it's completely irrelevant to the outcome of the game. In order for the A's to tie things up, somebody else has to get on base and score. In order for that 2nd run to get on base and score, the guy ahead of him on 3rd is going to be driven in. The sac fly was completely useless there, and if Johnson was trying to hit a sac fly on that AB, (Or Scutaro was trying to move the runner up to 3rd), then he(they're)'s an idiot. This was regarding the Pierre, Theriot, Ramirez hypothetical inning. The tying run was brought to the plate on Pierre's double. The "productive outs" in that inning were worthless. The point everyone else is making regarding the hypothetical is you're all assuming if the inning didn't go Double Productive out Run scoring productive out that it would go Double Unproductive out unproductive out unproductive out instead of Double unproductive out run scoring single unrproductive out walk run scoring single