Re: Boers & Bernstein, I enjoy them from time to time, find them pretty amusing, but I never really pay much attention to their opinions or sources. They're not sports guys, they're entertainment guys. Re: Manny, I tried to clarify earlier that the poster was calling Barrett a bad baseball player because he's bad on the basepaths and defense, implying that you can't be a good one if you are.(as he pointed out, even in good offensive years for Barret, he was still "a bad baseball player") My point on Manny being a LF hurting the argument is that he had the same problems that supposedly make a "bad baseball player" and he was doing it at a position which is easier to fill than catcher.