There's some real hindsight going on with regards to bringing back Lofton in '04. Patterson's first half line before getting injured in '03 was .298/.329/.511 with excellent defense in CF. IIRC, Corey was having an above average year up until he tanked in September of '04 as well. Moving your young stud prospect to the bench for a full year after he put up that line would make no sense. EDIT: I should specify, it looks right in hindsight, I do remember people aroudn here clamoring for Lofton to be brought back in the '03-'04 offseason, though I believe it was usually as a 4th OF, which he certainly would not have gone for.